Alan Thornett on Respect
Transcript of this video (4,128 words, machine-made)
These are YouTube's automatic captions, not a human transcript. There is no punctuation and no indication of who is speaking, and names and political vocabulary are often misheard. They are here so the talk can be searched. Check anything you intend to quote against the video.
only the next yeah um well I I suppose the the kind of short history of respect is that um it was formed in January 2004 um it went through its first year in which it um pretty rapidly expanded and generally went forward um it then for its uh subsequent two and a half years has basically gone into reverse and into decline um to the extent where now it has around 2,000 members just over um during that I mean I I think the I think the the the the sort of brief explanation of um of how that uh decline uh came about uh was uh that
um it reached the point when people realized a that um the S swp were exercising a very topown control in some respect and B that they had a perspective um for respect which certainly we disagree with and a lot of The Independents in respect disagreed with and that is that they treated it um as really just another campaign or United Fund of a special kind or the the the elect the Electoral arm the Electoral uh initiative of what they do um and we have always argued against that we've always argued that to build a new party to the left of Labor that can seriously challenge
in British politics you can't kind of half do it you can't can't be just a bit of what you do um you can only do it if it's the overarching thing that you do and that if you if you build it as a political party because um unless you build it as a political party you can't develop it politically uh for the task because clearly if a if you if if if an organization can go to challenge for political office and challenge for political power and put itself forward as an alternative it has to do that on all political fronts um and that means developing
as a political party having an internal life having its own political education doing all the things that political parties do um in order to shape itself up to to to carry out the task and for the last two and a half years at least since the this kind of clarify um that's been the battle in in in that's gone on um inside uh respect and it's happened at the last two conferences conference before last when there was a confrontation over it um when George Galloway told us that we should all enjoy was had a very good leadership we all enjoy and get on with it
and um and which caused a fair amount of friction and then the last conference um at which um uh by then the respect party platform had come together mainly from people that were uh um disillusioned or or or um or um uh became became critical of of its direction at the previous conference the last conference the respect party platform and we put forward then a number of things that to try to push it towards the direction of coming a party and basically we got tranced um at the conference um fairly small votes and um and and a huge uh um list of speakers against us
denouncing what we were doing and so on and after then uh generally it has gone no further there's more left there's more left I think for example people in Canada that we talked to immediately before that conference basically said we give it one more shot and see and see going anywhere and but it didn't they left so it's got narrower and narrower um and more and more uh really simply uh predominantly swp that's that's been the process uh and um that that General approach has has existed really as an alliance between the swp and George Gall really far as we can see differen is really
on this um however we then um over the last uh few weeks we've had George G's letter and George Galloway's letter um takes up um quite a few of the things that we've been we've been taken up um over that period of time um we had a respect party platform meeting on Saturday and um and we welome wel you know the the the the things that George Galloway is Raising um and we can support most of them um we can certainly support what he raises in terms of uh democracy um inide respect but he raises it from the point of view of appointments in the
office and people pop up and who knows who appointed them and all this kind of thing and uh and he also raises it from the point of view of decision making or or more precisely um carrying out of decisions um he complains that uh that you could make all kinds of decisions with National Council meetings but only certain decisions that fit in with certain other agendas are the ones that are picked up and run with um others allowed to as he says with on the vine and it's absolutely true I mean that's that's a that's a method that has has gone on um if it
fits in with another genda then all the power goes behind it if it doesn't then you never hear anything else about it and you can bang your head in the office and and you don't get anywhere and those those are valid criticisms and uh and we certainly support him on that um however um democracy would have to go quite a bit further than that I mean that's the problem as well and the issue that we've raised over the last two years has been the issue of the um the accountability of elected representes atives um which he doesn't mention um and um we we would have
to we would have to insist that uh that this is really an extremely important issue it's actually an issue both in terms of Westminster and it's an issue in terms of local government um and it mean it's a two-way thing as well I mean it means that there has to be and there isn't really in respect there isn't there isn't a proper mechanism in respect for what the MP is doing in Parliament feeding back into respect there isn't a proper mechanism for what the councilors are doing feeding back into respect um and and there isn't a proper mechanism to uh to ensure that what they're
doing is in line um with the policies of respect now it it wouldn't necessarily be on All Occasions I mean it would be time when there would be clashes on policy uh but um they need to they need to be properly regulated in an agreed way through through through the leading bodies none of this none of this has ever happened uh but we we certainly agree with him on that we certainly agree with him when he says that um that respects public profile is uh entirely inadequate and when he Praises um the uh the Manchester uh respect Branch for uh producing its own newspaper and
producing a tabloid um he said he says without that tabloid you wouldn't be a to find respect was at the demonstration at Labor Party Conference you wouldn't be a to find it was at the coronation of Gordon Brown if it hadn't been for the Tabloid and that's that's fair comment however uh we raised at every respect conference the need to have a national uh newspaper his own National newspaper both to put forward his views and as a mechanism for developing Collective political experience and developing respect politically um it's always been rejected it's always been rejected Ed both by the S um and by George Galloway
so uh so if if he's having second thoughts um in terms of a newspaper then this this would be um an extremely important important thing to happen um and so we hope we hope that that's the case um we also support him um on the issue of um of respects inability to take up the debates after John McDonald's uh failure to get on the in the ballot uh for labor leader uh we had a National Council uh just before that before the the before John McDonald failed to get on the list but it was already clear that he was going to fail to get on
the list and we had a National Council discussion on it and a lot of proposals were made along the lines that um this is another this is another water Shel of the labor left basically and all those that argue possible to reclaim the labor party uh this is another Watershed and uh and respect needs to uh be waiting on these debates it needs to take initiatives to discuss with the labor left the Trade union left the morning star and the cpb and all these kind of forces that must be in some kind of turmoil as a result of uh result of of of failure the
first failure since the 30s have been left to uh to to mount a challenge in a lead in a leadership election um and nothing came of it and he's absolutely right to take it up me the Morning Star had a conference um the the the rmt had a conference that that promoted discussion on this but respect had nothing and did nothing and he certainly he certainly wrote to take that up um and in fact um if if we look even the last week FR Fred has drawn my attention to uh the Morning Star over the last week because I mean and we've been arguing this
I mean I I I don't know how much I've passed it around but U but I I made a proposal in June myself to to the the officers to respect officers uh for an initiative towards uh CP in the morning star and uh and the trade un left people like Bob Crow U to open open up a fresh discussion on leg representation given that the whole situation was compounded by the McDonald defeat and U it's never been discussed this was June early June and it's never been discussed uh we we we now find in the Morning Star this week that um that Rob Griffith who's
the general secretary um of the cpb um is is is raising the issue for the first time he he's raised it that it may be necessary to eventually draw the conclusion that um the net can't be reclaimed and it might be NE might toone might be coming to form a new party um um he says the final crisis approaches for the whole Trade union movement and the non-sectarian left are we to have a mass party of Labor in Britain question mark if the labor movement cannot or will not reclaim the labor party from the privatize as the war MERS and the Thatcher fans it would
have to reestablish one does our movement have the leadership and vision to fulfill such a historic responsibility I mean it's quite a it's quite a statement now I'm not saying that the cpb would as a result to that all immediately change but that that is a direct result of McDonald's failure I mean they were all going home McDonald campaign is going to be a big step forward for the left in the labor party it's going to be the point of which the left starts to regenerate and what happened straight down the flugo and that's that's that that's that's the result of it and it also
shows uh that that that it's been a big mistake of respect a big mistake of respect to uh not not to intervene on that and to already be in discussing um on that so uh so we agree very much with George Galloway on that um but there's one thing there's one thing in particular um that George Galloway doesn't raise um in his matter um and that's the issue of the political profile of respect well the political profile what I mean is um the policies and program uh that appears on its election material in the course of an election I don't mean so much what it's
what's in its formal Manifesto uh but what appears on the streets in its leaflets and broads uh in in election campaign because something again that we've taken up now for the last two years is there's been a general dumbing down um of um of of of political material public material to very basic things and economics against neol liberalism all this kind of thing um but um but actually with no socialist content actually very rarely does the word socialism appear and very rarely is there an explicit socialist content there is in its Manifesto but not in what's reproduced from that on the streets and in my
opinion um I've argued this in the coedition of of of um of resistance is that to go anybody wants to go into a left organization going into this election on with Bland politics we'll get absolutely nowhere against Brown uh it'll be necessary to go in with clear radical socialist politics clearly showing that that you know cly showing the left alternative it also be necessary to have uh have very upfront and worked out a a program on ecology and climate change because this is something else that hardly ever appears um on on on the leaflets and and it's not going to be possible to win votes
away from the greens or or to or to have a clear intervention without a very strong ecological content to to it now he hasn't raised any of this and um and uh my my guess would be um that on this issue um we would probably have a difference with both the the swp um and and with George Galloway in terms of that kind of political profile but it is a very important issue because George Galloway says George Galloway starting point is very good I mean clear he looks from the big picture he has clearly decided that he's going to stand again for Parliament um he's
been you know whatever he's been saying about it he's now decided he's going to stand again for parli and um and he's looked at the landscape and realized a there's going to be an early general election now we don't know whether it's going to be could be this year could could be in the spring of next year but it's it's rather unlikely that it won't be it it seems the most likely option uh because the brown Banks is there and and the crisis of the Tory party is there and it might be the best shot he'll get so so so so there's likely to be
an early general election and he's look at respect and drawn the conclusion that respect is in no state to vote a general election now or in the next six or nine months um and so a problem he will be standing respected in no state to fight the election that that seems to be that seems to be the starting point made it's a pretty uh pretty um uh we reasonable starting point um now way there um so so he's he's putting the letter to to to make this to make make a challenge to the situation now if you read the letter I think it's it's reasonable
that it is a pretty systematic critique um of the politics of thep and how they R respect I it's inescapable that it is um and so from the time that the letter was issued um the the issue really has been how would the swp um respond to to the letter as the leading overwhelmingly the leading group um inside respect and I mean I've held the view right from the start of see the letter um that if the fs swp take the position that this is a big attack on us and we're going to defend the party so you know we're going to and drive towards
a confrontation then it's very difficult to see um how respect would survive such a confrontation now there has been as everybody will know no doubt there has been a delegation meeting between uh the S swp Central Committee um and um a delegation led by George Galloway um and I don't know what happened at it but um but it it didn't it didn't resolve anything at the end of it it didn't resolve anything and since that meeting um there has been um anual London meeting of um of s swp members last Friday night um 200 or so s swp members uh to discuss the situation and
um and and I quot it everything else um I've had no firsthand account of that meeting but from several second or third handic accounts which seem to fit together uh quite well um it's it's it's fairly clear um what has happened at that meeting and um and the the the way that things are currently learning up in respect in terms of debate um and it's dangerous opinion it's it's dangerous um the respect party platform Saturday decided to draft a a statement on all this where where we stand in terms of George Galloway's letter and where we stand in terms of the debates that are now
happening uh between the fwp and George Galloway and everything else and that will be out in in the next couple of days it's just being finally kind of agreed um but what the swp is saying uh about George Galloway now is that um The Divide in respect is between the left the swp and others on the left who defend a kind of socialist framework um for for for respect and and and George Galloway and S and and others uh who have who have gone over to uh to Communism this is this is this is what being said um it's a very dangerous well first of
all the use of communalism is is is is is is a whole problem in itself in terms of its connotations and everything else but if we leave if we leave that aside and we accept that uh what's being said or what's being meant by cism is um is um a major overemphasis on one particular minority community and making political concessions in the process if that's what is meant by it which probably is what it's meant um then um a lot of things arise from that because it is true it is true that there have been elements of that and this is something else that we've
taken up there has been uh political concessions of that kind um in fact I think the I think the support uh given to the uh the religious hatred bill um yeah religious hatred bill was was such a concession um so there have been political concessions but that hasn't all been an issue of George Gallow that's been something that's been in my opinion as much yes it has been George G um and uh and it was a problem because because um because you have to take against that you can't discuss that without looking at um the kind of games that respect has been able to make
in places like taham and in Birmingham where they have got big votes and and and won councel positions and and made big game very big games for the left and there was always major issues um in hamlets in particular birming is different because some Y is different uh but but um but in to hamlets there's always been a big issue about you know how how that how that respect group um develops and and everything else um there's always been a major issue there um there's always been an issue of what kind of political education you have and all that kind of thing and and how
you bring uh people that that that that came towards respect on a very hard anti-war position and Anti-Imperialist position you know how they one over to a much wider um uh socialist perspective has always been an issue um in there and it's a difficult problem nobody question it nobody uh would pretend it's other than a difficult question but now it's being said that oh well all these problems now in in in t Hamlet and the and my reply to it to all thing about those problems in T hamlets is that I've sat on the National Council and the National Council has never had a disc
about problems in tet never had a discussion on it I me it's the na Council it's had some very useful reports from the from from the group from the council group to the National Council what they're doing in the council doing this out and the other is had that but nobody's ever come to the National Council and said oh there's these great conflicts going on in Tower hamlets and they need discussing everything else never never happened and so there's there's there's all all kinds of suddenly say now it's you know it's all George Galloway's well over to communalism um is is a very dangerous road
and um and I think that we have to we have to oppose that and we also have to say I think i' for the last couple of minutes um and we also have to say George Galloway has made various proposals what he made a proposal at the end of his end of his document um for a new um uh high power he says um um committee to in which he's on and I'm on and some more on to run the next election campaign and basically it's a it's a border based thing it's not it weakens the swp representation stength as others that's basically what he
does um and he makes that proposal um as as a Way Forward um and there is a certain Merit in that uh but I think there's a few things we have to say about it as well and that is that if all that happens um in respect between now and its conference or or after its conference because all this is now heading for conference in November next conference is going to be like no other respect conference down about this heading to a conference in November but if all that happens uh as a result of all this is that a new committee gets set up with
nothing else substantial having changed then the new committee will have an absolutely hopeless task that's the problem um and so could support the setting up of a new committee but it must go alongside substantial other changes that's what it really means and really if you get if we get down to uh you know bottom line at the present time where respect is um it's respect will have difficulty in surviving it's a crisis I mean Geor Galloway said it's a crisis I me it is a CL it's even bigger CL than when he wrote it um if it's going to get to this then there's only
one possibility and that is the S swp makes major concessions major concessions in terms of how respect is run how its decision- making processes go its public profile its political profile there has to be there has to be concessions on all these things otherwise um it's very hard to see how it's going to get out of this crisis so that's the uh that's the conclusion of the the respect body St um when it comes out tomorrow um so we do need to play all those of us active in respect we need to play an active role in this I mean s has already had a
discussion on it had a discussion on the document last week um local branches should discuss it um and all its implications and the the only possibility is full and Frank discussion right through respect right up to the conference and some serious changes being made otherwise it's hard to see where the whole thing is going yeah