Socialist Resistance

An archive of socialistresistance.org, 2002–2022

Alan replies to the discussion

 ·  28 June 2016  ·  3:28

Alan Thornett of Socialist Resistance replies to the discussion at the London meeting on the outcome of the referendum.

Socialist Resistance public meeting on the EU referendum result, London (reply to the discussion)  ·  2016-06-28 (inferred from content; not stated in the archive)

This is a corrected machine transcript. It began as YouTube's automatic captions, which carry no punctuation and mishear names, and was corrected by hand against the recording: the speaker's own wording is kept, a reading that could not be settled is marked [?], and a passage that could not be recovered at all is marked [inaudible]. Every change is listed at the foot of the page. The recording is the authority; quote from it, not from this.

00:00 Alan Thornett: [inaudible] I'm trying to [inaudible] quite a few things to be — sorry. But we should recognise in this situation that everything is split, absolutely everything is split. The working class is split, the Tories are split, Labour is split, the left is split. Everything is split, because of an earthquake — you know, an earthquake that happened — but everything is split. And the only — the only thing, in actual fact, we've got two main parties — there are only two main parties because of the electoral system. If we had a democratic electoral system, the Tories would be split into two; one would join up with UKIP. Labour would split into two: a right-wing Labour Party and a much more radical Labour Party. That's where politics is. It's held together by the electoral system.

00:30 And what I was saying about PR, my point is it's very important that Labour adopts PR, because it's a winner, it's a vote attractor [?]. It's very important that Labour now [inaudible].

01:01 I don't share the amount of pessimism over Corbyn — than Mark, for example, [who] says now if Corbyn goes off the rails politically, he's finished. I mean, I can't judge that; but assuming that he doesn't go off the rails politically, I think the chances are that we could see another upsurge of young people around him, with the real possibility of winning. And Mark Serwotka was — I mean, actually, today Mark Serwotka defended him to the hilt. He said that what we've got to do is we've got to campaign to get thousands more people to join the Labour Party so that he has another resounding victory. That was Mark Serwotka. And that's not at all impossible; in fact I would have thought that it's possible.

01:33 Now, I don't think they can keep him off the ballot paper. I think that's a false debate, because the rules will be decided by the NEC, and if they kept him off the ballot paper then there'd be a legal challenge. It would be ruled out even legally. So I think they could just forget that: he's going to be on the ballot paper. The question is, is he going to win? And so I think that we've got to be part of that, getting every single person we possibly can in the Labour Party and getting the biggest vote possible.

02:04 So I think what I mean about a referendum — you know, it is a — it's very difficult to get round a referendum, and there's no way that we could say that a second referendum would be a better outcome than the existing one, because, as Roland says, they would call foul, and they would appeal to the — you know, "this has been overturned" — and you might get an even bigger exit vote in the second referendum. This is why I think that we have to focus on trying to have an input and influence in what is being proposed as a Brexit framework. And we need to follow it in detail. We need to expose what they're doing. We can't let them do it behind closed doors. And there needs to be an alternative Brexit agenda based on civil rights, democratic rights, everything else — a completely different Brexit agenda. And so I think that's the only way to go in this situation.

Correction notes (16)
  • Same meeting as Alan Thornett's opening talk (FW6ejyDxLMQ) and Luke Cooper's talk (4FnVWr_SWZw); see those files for the date inference. The opening seconds are garbled (the clip begins mid-sentence) and are marked [inaudible].
  • "the tour is a split labor is split" → "the Tories are split, Labour is split"; "only human terry parties" → "only two main parties"; "if we have a Democratic Left electoral systems the toy will be split" → "If we had a democratic electoral system, the Tories would be split"; "UK labour would split" → "UKIP. Labour would split".
  • "these held together bone by the electoral system" → "It's held together by the electoral system".
  • "about priv" → "about PR"; "a vote Bogut tractors" → "a vote attractor [?]".
  • "marks of Walker", "Mark sawako" → "Mark Serwotka" (PCS general secretary; spelling per SR archive). "Williard" dropped as a false start.
  • "we got a campaign those are the thousands of more people enjoy the Labour Party" → "we've got to campaign to get thousands more people to join the Labour Party".
  • "keep them on the ballot paper" → "keep him off the ballot paper" (the argument that follows — rules set by the NEC, legal challenge — is about excluding Corbyn); "NDC" → "NEC"; "liner party" → "Labour Party"; "biggest boat" → "biggest vote".
  • "where fendom", "random ever end up" → "a referendum", "[inaudible]"; "we won referendum" → "a second referendum".
  • "xing vote" → "exit vote"; "brexit framework", "Black Sea agenda", "back sender" → "Brexit framework", "Brexit agenda".

Settled by a second machine pass, 11 October 2026

The audio was transcribed again with faster-whisper, independently of YouTube's captions. Where the two recognisers agree, the reading is taken as settled; the changes are listed here because three of them overturn earlier corrections in the list above.

  • "if Corbyn goes off the rails politically, he's finished", not "if Corbyn goes, the left is politically finished". The captions gave "off the wells politically" and "doesn't offer Wales politically", which an earlier pass read as "the left is". The second pass hears "off the rails" in both places, which is what the captions were mangling, and the sentence that follows — "but assuming that he doesn't go off the rails politically" — now reads as it was spoken. The earlier reading changed the claim: Thornett was conditioning on Corbyn's own conduct, not predicting the end of the left.
  • "than Mark, for example", not "[inaudible], for example". The captions' "Denmark" is "than Mark". A Mark is answered here and Mark Serwotka is praised a minute later, but they need not be the same person, so no surname is supplied.
  • "as Roland says", not "as [inaudible] says". The captions' "as well and" is "as Roland"; Roland Rance speaks elsewhere in this corpus.
  • "Everything is split, because of an earthquake — you know, an earthquake that happened — but everything is split": two [inaudible] closed.
  • "It would be ruled out even legally"; "it's very difficult to get round a referendum".
  • "a vote attractor [?]": the captions gave "vote Bogut tractors" and the second pass "voter tractor". Both point at attractor rather than the vote-getter an earlier pass supplied, but neither is clean, so it stays marked.
  • Still unresolved: the opening clause, and "It's very important that Labour now [inaudible]" — both recognisers run out at the same place, so the sentence was not finished or not captured.