Socialist Resistance

An archive of socialistresistance.org, 2002–2022

Steve Hall on fracking

 ·  27 September 2015  ·  10:33

Imperialism, Globalisation and Climate Change, London  ·  26 September 2015

This is a corrected machine transcript. It began as YouTube's automatic captions, which carry no punctuation and mishear names, and was corrected by hand against the recording: the speaker's own wording is kept, a reading that could not be settled is marked [?], and a passage that could not be recovered at all is marked [inaudible]. Every change is listed at the foot of the page. The recording is the authority; quote from it, not from this.

> Note on this transcript. This is by far the most damaged recording in the collection. The speaker has a strong Lancashire accent and the automatic captions fail on roughly a third of it, in long stretches rather than single words. What follows recovers the argument, the names and the figures, which are secure; where the words cannot be recovered they are marked [inaudible] rather than guessed at. This one needs re-transcribing from the audio. Anyone quoting from it should listen to the recording first.

Steve Hall of the Lancashire anti-fracking movement, speaking before John Hilary at the same conference. Peter Deane, speaking later, plugs the One Million Climate Jobs pamphlet "again, as Steve did".

00:00 Steve Hall: I just want to start off by [saying] it would be dishonest of me to say that climate change and fracking is a link that everybody involved in the anti-fracking movement draws, because that would be very far from the truth. In fact, there's various prominent people involved in the anti-fracking movement such as Ian Crane, who's a conspiracy theorist; and another guy who was down at Barton Moss used to do quite a lot of singing there, and the third verse of one of his songs was "you can stick your global warming up your arse". So, you know,

00:33 there isn't that direct link, [for] some people, [that] the link with fracking is something that's got to be taken into the movement [?]. Which I would say — perhaps you might think this flippant — is more driven by the effects it may have on people's house prices than by concern about climate change. And actually, whilst we might disapprove of that, that's actually what's driving a big resistance in virtually every single community in this country where they're proposing to do it.

01:03 [There's] now, I think it was, 450 different groups. Everywhere they try [and] apply [to] do it, [the] first thing that happens [is] a massive response from [the] community, across all social classes and everything. And [that's] one of the reasons that the governments are going to have a big problem trying to carry this through. And in fact I would say most of [the] people involved in it [are] pretty optimistic that we're going to win on this one. So far the anti-fracking movement is basically undefeated. A lot of people [would]

01:34 say that the key thing is all about [air] quality, potential pollution of the water supply, and the traffic going through — all of which are very valid points in their own right, and obviously everybody involved would agree with them. Well, the tactic right from the beginning of this [has been] to link it directly with climate change: instead of being an "anti" movement, you know, just against fracking, [I'd] say we should really be a "for" movement instead. One of the things that was very strong is the pamphlet —

02:05 [I] would urge you [to] buy copies of [it], everybody — the One Million Climate Jobs pamphlet. And [we] said: instead of fracking, what we really want is this, or something like this. That particular position has gone from strength to strength. It's backed by Friends of the Earth, War on Want, supported by the Green Party. I would say [it's] possibly just about the majority opinion in the movement now: that instead of investing in fracking, what we should be doing is investing in renewables and energy conservation, things like that. And that's a much

02:35 sounder idea than fracking, [devastating the] countryside and polluting us and increasing climate change. And I'd say I usually speak on platforms where everybody before me says, you know, earth pollution, water pollution, whatever, and I have to take a position and say: well, even if it didn't cause [all that], it did add to the threat of climate change, which it clearly does. I've been on radio interviews where I've had so-called experts from Cuadrilla, or one of the other fracking companies, arguing that shale gas is a good transition fuel, that

03:09 it's a good way to transition from coal and oil into renewables. But the reality is, researchers at Cornell University in America carried out [a study of the methane] involved in fracking, which shows an average leak of between two and a half percent and nine and a half percent of all the wells. That's included abandoned wells, many obviously recently been abandoned because of the low oil prices — that has basically made some of them uneconomic. When you bear in mind that methane gas is

03:40 about 25 times more potent [as] a greenhouse gas than what CO2 is — obviously, leaks of between two and a half and eight percent of something that's 25 times more potent than [CO2], [and] if you were burning the gas [it] produce[s] the CO2 [anyway]. Obviously I would say there's a good case [?] of reopening coal-fired power stations as a transition. So, you know, as I said: even if it was safe — "safe with knobs on" — we don't actually need it. We use that phrase very often.

04:11 Somebody actually used that phrase, [that it has] to be safe "with knobs on". Because we shouldn't [risk] the water and [we] don't need it, when there's other things like that at our disposal which would create more jobs. [The] expectation of jobs created by the fracking industry started off — they [paid] a company, I think [it was] called AMEC, to do research, [and] they came up with about 30,000 it would employ if it was all [to go ahead]. And then [the] following week David Cameron inflated that himself to 60,000. He just

04:41 arbitrarily increased [it] by [a] hundred percent. And then a few months later the House of Lords said quarter of a million. Even if it was quarter of a million — and, you know, it's totally grossly exaggerated — [inaudible]. We estimate about 20 times more jobs would come from investing the same type of money in that. It would also help us reduce our energy bills. They keep saying that fracking will reduce our energy bills, but the reality is it won't: this gas market is determined

05:12 internationally. What will do [it] is things [like] insulating people's houses and things like that — [that] will bring the bills down. It would also help us to secure our own domestic energy supply, reduce CO2 emissions by eighty-five percent and save us — the big thing I always argue — Lord Stern was asked by Gordon Brown's government to do a report on the cost of climate change. The result of his investigation was [that] he estimated it would cost twenty times more in ten years' time to have the

05:44 same effect on climate change. I want to use this example: imagine somebody could have said your roof's knackered. You fix it now, it'll cost you a thousand pound; if you leave it for 10 years and the water gets in, not only will it cost you more than that, but your gable end could fall off, the front of your house could come in, you could end up with a catastrophe that costs you 20 times more. Most sane people would — would possibly even take a loan out, right? — to save the massive cost down the line. And yet

06:14 here we are: we have a government that's basically saying stuff like that for a game of soldiers, we're going to do this instead. So, big problem there. In terms of news updates about where we're at: [the] government's [having] difficulty trying to roll this programme out. It's determined to do so — so it says — [and has] brought out a bill, a law called the Infrastructure Act, I don't know whether any of you know about that, just before the general election, which basically allows them, [if] it's a big project in

06:46 the national interest, it can be sanctioned by the [government] directly. And also, as a result of the recent victory we had in Lancashire, where the local county council planners turned down Cuadrilla's application, they're also introducing measures now that [say] if after 16 weeks local planners, councils, can['t] make a decision, [the government] will just step in and make the decision for them — which, you can imagine what will happen there. We've also [got] a situation just close to Wigan where I live, Skelmersdale, where they

07:18 wanted to dump a lot of the frack fluid and various other waste in this landfill site in Skelmersdale. It also got turned down by Lancashire County Council as well. By every single elected body that could possibly stop it, [it was] turned down. So what they did was they [made it] into a bigger project, so [it] then came under these Infrastructure Act directives, and now that's going ahead and it's going to be five times bigger than the original one. So it tells you what's right with that.

07:48 And they're going to literally — well, I live near Wigan — dump all the waste, or a lot of it. Obviously when you think that only a few years ago they were going on about localism, and they were going to change the law to allow local residents to object to houses being built: you know, when it comes to fracking you're not going to get a say in that. We're now in the fourteenth licensing round in terms of areas up for grabs for potential drillers

08:18 to come in and explore. These include sites [of] Special Scientific Interest, [areas] of outstanding natural beauty — [and] they want to frack them. But it was interesting, and I'm sure you'll like this: in all of the south of England there's all these areas being given out, but there's one place where there seems to be [nothing] going on, and if you look at it, if you zoom in — Witney constituency. I wonder who lives there. But it's not happening in Witney.

08:50 So, the attitude of the anti-fracking movement is that we can fight this on a number of fronts — politically, and economically, by basically just making life hell for them, [making] it cost IGas an absolute fortune to do this stuff. At Barton Moss there was a big attack on the investors, you know, saying it's not going to be worth your while if you do it. But if you look at the share prices currently for Cuadrilla and people like IGas, they're

09:22 absolutely at rock bottom; few people want to take up these sites because they're concerned about the opposition they're going to get. And basically the government's in a crisis here, but determined to drive ahead with it. And all I can say, in terms of the movement that I've been directly involved in — I've been [in it] four years, I know most of the people who are involved in it — is that they can't wait for the government to come at them. They're that confident that we'll build a mass movement and defeat it. So I think that's all pretty

09:53 well and good. Obviously people like me are pushing the climate change thing. Various things have come out of it, such as, for example, next — the week after next — Sunday is the big demo in Manchester; on the following week, in Manchester, a conference on climate change, Time to Act, which I shall be going to. I don't know if any of you stayed up in Manchester for that; you might be interested. But the report I would give, in terms of where we as an anti-fracking movement are, is very upbeat, pretty confident — and we can't wait for the buggers to attack us.

Correction notes (27)
  • "Ian crear is a conspiracy theorist" → "Ian Crane", a prominent figure in the anti-fracking movement at the time.
  • "I was down at bar but mas" → "Barton Moss", the anti-fracking protest camp at Salford, named again near the end of the talk.
  • "you can stick your mobile warming up your ass" → "your global warming up your arse" — the line is the entire point of the opening anecdote.
  • "the pump word ... the climate jobs pamphlet" → "the pamphlet ... the One Million Climate Jobs pamphlet", the Campaign against Climate Change trade union group publication that Peter Deane plugs later in the day "again, as Steve did".
  • "the tack Arctic right from the beginning" → "the tactic"; "instead of being an unsafe movement" → "instead of being an 'anti' movement", against which he sets "a 'for' movement".
  • "share gases would transition fuel" → "shale gas is a transition fuel"; "from cold and our list of into renewables" → "from coal and oil into renewables".
  • "an average link of between two and a half percent" → "an average leak" — the finding the argument rests on.
  • "that's included abundant wells, many obviously recently been abundant because of the law oil prices" → "abandoned wells ... recently been abandoned because of the low oil prices".
  • "researcher cornell university" → "researchers [at] Cornell University" — correct. The captions' "graffiti", in "Bartoli and graffiti involved in fracas", is almost certainly Ingraffea, the Cornell co-author of the methane leakage work; the surrounding words cannot be recovered, so the attribution is left out of the text.
  • "they [paid] a company, I think [it was] called AMEC" → from "the cold air Mac"; AMEC produced the government's strategic environmental assessment for shale gas.
  • "Lord stern us by God roads government" → "Lord Stern was [asked] by Gordon Brown's government" — the Stern Review, commissioned when Brown was Chancellor.
  • "turned down by like Security Council" → "by Lancashire County Council", which refused Cuadrilla's applications in June 2015; the same misreading produces "the recent literally we had it like issue" earlier.
  • "local plumbers councils" → "local planners, councils".
  • "the infrastructure act ... a lot of whether any of you nor bad Luck's just before the general election" → the Infrastructure Act, passed just before the 2015 general election; the clause between is unrecoverable.
  • "people are a gas" → "people [like] IGas", the UK shale company.
  • "only a few years ago toys were going on about localism" → "the Tories"; "change the law to local residents from jet two houses being built" → "[so] local residents [could] object to houses being built".
  • "whiteness", "Whitney" and "witness" → Witney, David Cameron's constituency. The joke — that every sort of protected land has been licensed except the Prime Minister's own seat — survives only because the name appears three times.
  • "up there is about studying national natural beauty" → "[areas] of outstanding natural beauty".
  • "conference on climate change time to act" → Time to Act, the Campaign against Climate Change event.
  • "des moines Manchester" → "the big demo in Manchester".

Settled by a second machine pass, 11 October 2026

The audio was transcribed again with faster-whisper, independently of YouTube's captions. This was one of the three transcripts flagged at the head of this corpus as substantially incomplete; it no longer is.

  • The closing line was missing: "and we can't wait for the buggers to attack us", which is also the point of the sentence before it — "they can't wait for the government to come at them, they're that confident that we'll build a mass movement and defeat it".
  • The Witney joke was lost. "there's one place where there seems to be [nothing] going on, and if you look at it, if you zoom in — Witney constituency. I wonder who lives there." (Witney was David Cameron's seat.) Our text had the punchline as [inaudible].
  • He was not the singer. "Another thing — I was down at Barton Moss, [they] used to do a lot of singing" is in fact "another guy who was down at Barton Moss used to do quite a lot of singing": the man with the song about global warming is one of the conspiracy theorists he is distancing the movement from, not himself.
  • The opening claim was inverted. "it would be dishonest of me to say that climate change and fracking is a link that everybody in the movement draws" — not "something that everybody endorses".
  • "the House of Lords said quarter of a million"; "this gas market is determined internationally"; "your gable end could fall off, the front of your house could come in"; "a law called the Infrastructure Act, I don't know whether any of you know about that"; "as a result of the recent victory we had in Lancashire"; "making life hell for them"; "areas up for grabs for potential drillers"; "the big demo in Manchester on Sunday"; "that has basically made some of them uneconomic".
  • Where the second pass is wrong and ours stands: it renders Cornell University as "an old university" and invents a researcher's name; it gives "Electric County Council" for Lancashire and "Schemersdale" for Skelmersdale. Ours are kept.
  • Still marked: "there's a good case [?] of reopening coal-fired power stations as a transition", which neither pass makes comfortable sense of, and the aside after "grossly exaggerated".