Socialist Resistance

An archive of socialistresistance.org, 2002–2022

Scottish Party Ter an indeperdent socialist scotland

Socialist Resistance pilot issue October 2002  |  page 19

This is scanned newsprint, not web text. The original PDFs carried no text layer at all, so every word here was read off the page by OCR. Expect dropped opening letters, run-together words and wrong characters. There was no contents page to cut the paper up by, so the articles were found from the size of their headlines: a headline may carry its kicker, and where an article ran beside a boxed panel a few lines of the neighbour can appear. The scanned issue is the authority; this text is here so the words can be found at all.

There was a very vigorous, robust debate earler this year on a proposal to ensure gender equality on the party lists for Holyrood (i.e. in the winnable seats).

There was division on this issue at every level from the executive down to the branches. This division also affected platforms with members of the ISM, the SW platform etc speaking and voting on both sides of the debate.

The final decision, which I personally supported, was to go for gender equality. There are eight regions in Scotland; our party list in four of these regions will be headed by a woman and tour by a man.

The selection of candidates takes place on a one member-one vote basis, with those unable to attend the selection meetings entitled to a postal vote.

Members are presented with two lists, one male and one female. In a region where it has been decided to have a female candidate on the number one spot on the list, the second and third spot will be taken by the top two male candidates, with numbers four and five female. And of course, vice versa where the top of the list is a man.

There are potentially nine winnable seats in Scotland for the SSP: we could win two list seats in Glasgow and one in each of the other seven regions - though that will be a tall order and we would be happy with half that number of MSPs. But if we were to win all nine, we would have five women MSPs and four men.

Initial indications suggest that men will tend to dominate among the first-pastthe-post candidates which are selected by the members in local constituencies.

Because none of these are likely to be winnable, there was a feeling among supporters of 50-50 system that it would be better to concentrate on the winnable

party list seats at this stage. Maybe there will be proposals for twinning of constituencies or whatever, but that's something for the membership to decide in the

future.

Has the SWP's decision to join the

SSP been positive, or has it

resulted in problems for the party!

The Socialist Workers platform the SSP in terms of finance and

activity. My estimation is that most SSP

members and most SW platform members would agree that the involvement

of the SW platform has been generally

positive.

Up until now, there has been no senous political divisions in the party. Policies

that some people thought might prove

contentious, such as the SSP's support for

an independent socialist Scotland, have

platform members. stage to win seats in the four regions that make up the Central Belt." On both the anti-war movement and the anticorporate movement our approach has been shaped by the old green slogan, Think Global, Act Local. •••

There have been some local tensions in a few branches. Some non-SW members feel the SW platform still tends operates as a regimented caucus and hasn't yet fully adapted to the new terrain of working through the SSP.

The ISM has an advantage in that respect, because it has been operating on this terrain for six and a half years now, generally been accepted by most SW including the period of the Scottish Socialist Alliance. The ISM also broke with "Across all eight regions of Scotland we stand a fighting chance of winning a seat, though we'd be happy at this the CW and the Socialist Party of England and Wales, which means that we're not under any external pressures. How do you respond to the criticism that the ISM underestimates the importance of the global justice and anti-war movements?

ersonally, I haven't heard these

criticisms and I would be surprised

if anyone suggested that the ISM underestimates the anti-war movement.

Last year, when the bombing of Afghanistan began, I travelled to the Afghanistan-Pakistan border to report on the ground for the Scottish Socialist Voice and to forge links with Afghan and Pakistani socialists.

The SSP was the only left party in the world and the SSV was the only left newspaper in the world to send someone out ISM and the SSP is generally drawn from the lowest paid, most exploited sections of the working class.

It's not always easy to find the time or the money to participate in a demo in Brussels, Genoa or Seville or a conference in Florence

We do try to participate in these events. But mobilising a group of activists to a demo or conference in Europe is not the be all and the end all of the anti-capitalist movement.

Sometimes you can make a more powerful contribution to that global strug gle by mobilising a local community to occupy their closure-threatened community centre, or leading a successful battle of low paid workers against a multinational like Sodexho, or by building mass support across the country for a campaign to proevents.

Especially after the Scottish elections next May, the SSP may be in a strong position to play a major part in international mobilisations.

But we have to remember that a party like the Rifondazione Communista was only able to mobilise the working class of Italy onto the streets of Italy because it had built a real base in workplaces and communities in the course of a decade of painstaking local campaigning What are the SSP's prospects in the upcoming Assembly elections?

The Herald newspaper carries a monthly poll conducted by System 3, which is widely regarded as the most reliable gauge of voting intentions in Scotland.

For each of the past three months, the SSP has stood steady at 8 per cent on the second ballot.

A regional breakdown of the poll sug gests that we could get 7 MSPs elected, the same number as the Tory Party Across all eight regions of Scotland we stand a fighting chance of winning a seat though we'd be happy at this stage to win seats in the four regions that make up the Central Belt

If we do achieve 8 per cent, that would represent a quadrupling of our vote since first Scottish election in 1999

It would be the highest vote in percentage terms yet achieved by any of the new anti-capitalist parties that have emerged in

Europe over the past decade or so

As well as standing a full slate of list candidates across Scotland, we also plan to

stand in all 73 constituency seats, with

maybe a few exemptions where there is

an independent socialist candidate such as

Denis Canavan in the frame.

We also plan to stand in hundreds of

council seats the same day

The ISG also published this on its own website — read that text

The International Socialist Group, which produced Socialist Resistance, carried the paper's articles on its own site as well. The text below is that site's own HTML, recovered from the Internet Archive, so it carries none of the OCR faults above. It is not a correction of the printed article: the two versions differ, and the printed page remains the text of record. The ISG titled it “Putting socialism back in the mainstream”.

Three and a half years ago people from the Scottish Socialist Alliance, including Scottish Militant Labour, took the initiative to form the Scottish Socialist Party. To some it seemed like a wild adventure that would fall on its face. But according to ALAN McCOMBES, a central leader of the SSP and a member of its International Socialist Movement platform, the SSP has helped put socialism back into the political mainstream.

SR: After several years experience, what’s your balance sheet of the decision to set up the SSP? What has it achieved?

When we first began discussing he idea of a new party, we pointed to the stark contradiction between the potential support for socialism and the harsh reality that the active forces of socialism in Scotland – as in the rest of the UK – were weaker than they had ever been throughout most of the twentieth century.

On the eve of the SNP conference five senior party activists with 75 years combined membership of the SNP have defected to the SSP.

Even those of us who were most optimistic about the potential for a new party have been surprised at how comprehensively we have managed to turn that position round.

From a handful of branches of the old Scottish Socialist Alliance, the SSP now has over 70 branches in every corner of Scotland.

Over the three and a half years since the launch of the SSP, we’ve drawn thousands of people into political activity for the first time.

That doesn’t mean we have thousands of hard core cadres, but we do have at least several thousand people who are identified as SSP members in their workplaces and communities. In a small country like Scotland that has a huge impact. We’ve also politicised tens of thousands more who are not yet politically active but who have been influenced by the SSP and generally identify with the politics of the SSP.

We’ve certainly dragged the ideology of anti-capitalism, of socialism, back into the political mainstream.

Not only has the SSP rebuilt the forces of socialism in Scotland, but we’ve reconstructed socialism on a completely difference basis from the past when it was heavily influenced by Stalinism and by top-down old Labour style parliamentary reformism.

Although there are different versions and interpretations of socialism within the SSP, there is also a remarkable degree of unity around certain core principles, such as anti-Stalinism, internationalism, support for direct action and defiance of the law, support for republicanism and for the break up of the British state.

There is very little to report on the negative side of the balance sheet. I think it would fair to say that even those groups and individuals within the old Scottish Socialist Alliance who were opposed to, or hesitant about, transforming the alliance into a party would now acknowledge that the move has been an unqualified success.

Certainly, it’s hard to imagine anyone ever suggesting that we should revert back to the structure of the Scottish Socialist Alliance.

How widespread is the influence of the SSP? Does it have real influence outside of Glasgow and the West of Scotland?

One of the most remarkable achievements of the SSP has been to spread the influence and establish active forces of socialism beyond the traditional ghettos of the left.

Before the launch of the SSP, socialist organisations, including the SSA, Scottish Militant Labour, and the Socialist Workers Party tended to be concentrated almost exclusively in urban Scotland, especially in the main cities.

Now the SSP has sunk roots in areas which had never before been touched by socialism. For example, in the Highlands and Islands we now have fourteen branches. People in cities can sometimes forget that the class divide in places like the Highlands can appear even more stark than in the cities. You have the landed aristocracy, the hunting and shooting brigade, who attract huge publicity when they protest against bans on foxhunting or whatever. But most people in the Highlands or the south of Scotland are low paid workers scraping a living in bars, shops, hotels, transport and so on.

“The Scottish Parliament can’t close down the Trident nuclear submarine bases, or refuse use of Scottish troops in Afghanistan or Iraq, because defence is controlled by Westminster”

Recent polls have shown a wide spread of support for the SSP. While we’re still moving forward in the traditional socialist stronghold of Glasgow, we are moving forward even faster in other parts of Scotland where we have started from scratch.

Glasgow will probably always be our strongest area, but other parts of Scotland are now beginning to narrow that gap.

Has the Scottish Parliament been a real gain for ordinary Scottish people? Has it resulted in better social conditions?

The Scottish Parliament has been a democratic gain, there’s no doubt about that. Politicians are under the magnifying glass as never before and now have to take responsibility for their own decisions rather than just blame everything on Westminster. The partly proportional electoral system is a big step forward. It’s allowed the SSP, the Green Party and independents like Dennis Canavan to emerge. It’s also led to a hung parliament and even on occasion, the defeat of the Scottish Executive (the equivalent of the Cabinet) – notably when Tommy Sheridan’s bill to outlaw warrant sales succeeded in the teeth of government opposition.

But the other side of it is that the Parliament is reliant on a block grant from Westminster and can only shuffle that cash around rather than generate extra resources to improve public services or tackle poverty.

It’s also severely restricted in what it can and cannot do. It can’t close down the Trident nuclear submarine bases, for example, or refuse use of Scottish troops in Afghanistan or Iraq, because defence is controlled by Westminster.

It can’t impose a wealth tax on the rich; it can’t increase the minimum wage; it can’t reverse the anti-union legislation; it has no control over Corporation Tax; it can’t open Scotland up to asylum seekers even though we live in an empty country with an ageing population.

There is a widespread sense of disillusionment that the Scottish Parliament has failed to make any real difference to the lives of ordinary people. But there is no support for a return to direct Westminster rule. Exactly the opposite – recent polls have shown a striking rise in support for full fiscal autonomy, in other words, economic independence.

How is the Blair government viewed in Scotland?

As is no doubt also the case in other traditional Labour strongholds such as Wales and the North of England, there is quite widespread disillusionment with Blair and the Labour Party.

Support for the Tories has collapsed over the years in Scotland. The last poll showed them running neck with the SSP on about eight per cent.

The Tory collapse has probably saved Labour’s skin in Scotland because 20 years ago the Tories could have relied on around 30 per cent of the electorate. Most of those ex-Tory voters have either literally died out or switched to other parties, mainly to Labour.

But at the same time, traditional Labour among the working class has itself been haemorrhaging to the SNP – and more recently – to the SSP, both of which are perceived to be to be the left of Labour.

The SNP has also swung to the right over the past decade, but its careful not to go too far and on certain issues, such as nuclear weapons, privatisation and PFI, the level of the minimum wage, trade union rights and racism, can still appear quite radical.

But although the general public perception of the SNP is that is a left party, many SNP activists have a clearer understanding of the direction that the party is moving. This week, on the eve of the SNP conference five senior party activists with 75 years combined membership of the SNP defected to the SSP. More are likely to follow in the coming weeks and months.

The three parties that are seen as radical – the SNP, the SSP, and the Greens – will probably take 40-45 per cent of the vote in the Scottish elections next May. These three parties are also pro-independence, which shows how fragile the United Kingdom actually is.

The SSP recently had an important debate on parity for women on the candidates list. How did that debate go?

There was a very vigorous, robust debate earlier this year on a proposal to ensure gender equality on the party lists for Holyrood (i.e. in the winnable seats).

There was division on this issue at every level from the executive down to the branches. This division also affected platforms with members of the ISM, the SW platform etc speaking and voting on both sides of the debate.

The final decision, which I personally supported, was to go for gender equality. There are eight regions in Scotland; our party list in four of these regions will be headed by a woman and four by a man. The selection of candidates takes place on a one member-one vote basis, with those unable to attend the selection meetings entitled to a postal vote. Members are presented with two lists, one male and one female. In a region where it has been decided to have a female candidate on the number one spot on the list, the second and third spot will be taken by the top two male candidates, with numbers four and five female. And of course, vice versa where the top of the list is a man.

There are potentially nine winnable seats in Scotland for the SSP: we could win two list seats in Glasgow and one in each of the other seven regions – though that will be a tall order and we would be happy with half that number of MSPs. But if we were to win all nine, we would have five women MSPs and four men.

Initial indications suggest that men will tend to dominate among the first-past-the-post candidates which are selected by the members in local constituencies. Because none of these are likely to be winnable, there was a feeling among supporters of 50-50 system that it would be better to concentrate on the winnable party list seats at this stage. Maybe there will be proposals for twinning of constituencies or whatever, but that’s something for the membership to decide in the future.

Has the SWP’s decision to join the SSP been positive, or has it resulted in problems for the party?

The Socialist Workers platform make a significant contribution to the SSP in terms of finance and activity. My estimation is that most SSP members and most SW platform members would agree that the involvement of the SW platform has been generally positive.

Up until now, there has been no serious political divisions in the party. Policies that some people thought might prove contentious, such as the SSP’s support for an independent socialist Scotland, have generally been accepted by most SW platform members.

On both the anti-war movement and the anti-corporate movement our approach has been shaped by the old green slogan, Think Global, Act Local.

There have been some local tensions in a few branches. Some non-SW members feel the SW platform still tends operates as a regimented caucus and hasn’t yet fully adapted to the new terrain of working through the SSP.

The ISM has an advantage in that respect, because it has been operating on this terrain for six and a half years now, including the period of the Scottish Socialist Alliance. The ISM also broke with the CWI and the Socialist Party of England and Wales, which means that we’re not under any external pressures.

How do you respond to the criticism that the ISM underestimates the importance of the global justice and anti-war movements?

Personally, I haven’t heard these criticisms and I would be surprised if anyone suggested that the ISM underestimates the anti-war movement. Last year, when the bombing of Afghanistan began, I travelled to the Afghanistan-Pakistan border to report on the ground for the Scottish Socialist Voice and to forge links with Afghan and Pakistani socialists.

The SSP was the only left party in the world and the SSV was the only left newspaper in the world to send someone out there at that time

The Scottish Socialist Voice’s coverage of the war in Afghanistan and its more recent coverage of the threatened war in Iraq stands comparison with any socialist paper in the world.

On both the anti-war movement and the anti-corporate movement our approach has been shaped by the old green slogan, Think Global, Act Local.

We have put more emphasis on getting the message across and in getting people involved right here in Scotland, where we can have the biggest effect.

People in London sometimes forget that it’s cheaper and quicker for them to travel to Paris or Brussels than it is for someone in Glasgow or Edinburgh to travel to London. The membership of the ISM and the SSP is generally drawn from the lowest paid, most exploited sections of the working class.

It’s not always easy to find the time or the money to participate in a demo in Brussels, Genoa or Seville or a conference in Florence.

We do try to participate in these events. But mobilising a group of activists to a demo or conference in Europe is not the be all and the end all of the anti-capitalist movement.

Sometimes you can make a more powerful contribution to that global struggle by mobilising a local community to occupy their closure-threatened community centre, or leading a successful battle of low paid workers against a multinational like Sodexho, or by building mass support across the country for a campaign to provide free meals to every school student. That’s not to deny the importance of coming together in big international events.

Especially after the Scottish elections next May, the SSP may be in a strong position to play a major part in international mobilisations.

But we have to remember that a party like the Rifondazione Communista was only able to mobilise the working class of Italy onto the streets of Italy because it had built a real base in workplaces and communities in the course of a decade of painstaking local campaigning.

What are the SSP’s prospects in the upcoming Assembly elections?

The Herald newspaper carries a monthly poll conducted by System 3, which is widely regarded as the most reliable gauge of voting intentions in Scotland.

For each of the past three months, the SSP has stood steady at 8 per cent on the second ballot.

A regional breakdown of the poll suggests that we could get 7 MSPs elected, the same number as the Tory Party. Across all eight regions of Scotland we stand a fighting chance of winning a seat, though we’d be happy at this stage to win seats in the four regions that make up the Central Belt.

If we do achieve 8 per cent, that would represent a quadrupling of our vote since first Scottish election in 1999. It would be the highest vote in percentage terms yet achieved by any of the new anti-capitalist parties that have emerged in Europe over the past decade or so.

As well as standing a full slate of list candidates across Scotland, we also plan to stand in all 73 constituency seats, with maybe a few exemptions where there is an independent socialist candidate such as Denis Canavan in the frame.

We also plan to stand in hundreds of council seats the same day.