Socialist Resistance

An archive of socialistresistance.org, 2002–2022

Build broad anti-capitalist parties!

 |  Socialist Resistance Rouge- ESF Special  |  page 22-23

This is newsprint, transcribed by hand. The automatic reading of this page cut the article up and welded its columns together, so the text below was transcribed from the page image instead. It should be free of the usual OCR faults. The scanned issue remains the authority.

When we look at the evolution of the global justice movement since 1999 it is clear that today the neoliberal discourse is in crisis. Hegemonic in the 1980s and 1990s, in particular after the fall of the Berlin Wall, it is now on the defensive.

On the social plane, its failure is now obvious in the eyes of broad layers of the population, hit hard by the generalized regression it has led to. In addition, certain scandals have revealed the absurdity of the system, whether the Enron affair in the United States, or the banning by pharmaceutical laboratories of generic anti-AIDS drugs. For millions of people, the incompatibility between neoliberal policies and the satisfaction of social needs is now obvious.

At the same time, in Europe, the institutional left, although dominant at the electoral level, does not represent a real alternative. The Communist Parties, when they still resist, hardly offer a substantial alternative, and they are subordinate to the social democratic parties.

The latter have tried to affirm the possibility of a social liberal 'third way'. The facts have shown everywhere in Europe that the means for such a way did not exist.

The social democrats are condemned to go along with neoliberalism, and carry out, at different rhythms, the anti-social "reforms" demanded by the employers.

This was particularly obvious when, out of 15 EU countries, 13 were led by social democratic governments, and there was no left turn in European neoliberal policy. In fact, as far as concrete policy is concerned, it is increasingly clear that it is necessary to choose between neoliberal policies in the service of capitalist globalization, and an anti-capitalist orientation to satisfy the social needs of the people.

In this context, there is thus a broad space for a political alternative. At the same time, the phase has ended where, at the level of the social movement, nothing seemed possible any more, where a massive feeling of political impotence and fatalism dominated among activists.

New activist forces have emerged in recent years, within the movement for global justice and in its wake. They have undermined the credibility of neoliberalism, revealing the coherence of a system combining social regression and military offensives.

These new activist generations are able to renew the traditional labour movement by merging with it. They have a new perspective, emancipatory, internationalist, anti-imperialist, feminist and ecologist.

Youth are particularly prominent in this current. It has its own symbols, methods of action (disobedience) and organisational methods, breaking with the dominant political culture in the traditional movements. There is thus not only a political space but also the forces available to build the alternative.

To advance in this direction, debates are of course necessary within the movements, in terms of political orientation. It is necessary to discuss with currents which for the moment, even though they criticize certain effects of neoliberalism, do not call into question the basis of the system.

But there are also currents which fundamentally criticize capitalism and which reject the idea of taking part in governments which manage the system, but which do not draw the same conclusions as us on the need at a given moment for a revolutionary rupture.

These currents, because they are clearly opposed to capitalism, must take their place in a broad and pluralist anti-capitalist party.

Everywhere where these forces exist, our objective is to support this type of regroupment – in a respectful but close relationship with the social movement. That obviously implies debating without any sectarianism, and avoiding a policy of self-affirmation.

We need to win support in society which breaks the monopoly exercised by the parties on the left which follow social-liberalism, which also implies having elected representatives at the local, regional, national and European levels.

This perspective must be made credible, to avoid being trapped in a logic of the lesser evil, which benefits the social-liberal left at the electoral level.

Of course, such regroupments can only function on the basis of pluralism, which allows both convergence and debate, and, in what concerns us, the maintenance of a revolutionary Marxist current as an accepted element within a broader whole.

page 23 of the scan

We should not hide the difficulties which are in front of us. In particular, it should be noted that at this stage, it appears difficult to find partners on the existing left.

For the moment there is no broad current present within this left, neither in the timorous tendencies of the social democratic left, nor in the Communist Parties, whose crisis (with the partial exception of the Italian PRC) has not generated an anti-capitalist project and a democratic functioning, nor in the big Green parties which have not developed a real political and social alternative, and some of whom have passed to the other side of the fence (in Germany for example).

That does not mean that, in these parties and the social movement, there is no interest in or openness to an anti-capitalist recomposition. It can take various forms.

We don't conclude from this that we should be diverted from an orientation to these traditonal parties and their militants.

On the contrary, it is essential to widen recomposition in this direction by a systematic policy of collaboration and convergence so as to create a very broad pole of attraction in order to defeat social neoliberalism.

But the fundamental conclusion which results from this, is that it will depend, much more than in the past, on the development of a strong and autonomous pole and an external relationship of force to attract and organize these sympathies.

It is urgent and necessary to take steps forward in the direction of broad, pluralist and representative parties, which are anti-capitalist, internationalist, ecologist and feminist and which, deeply attached to the social question, defend to the end the demands of labour and oppose all forms of domination, while basing themselves on the self-organisation of those who fight.