Socialist Resistance

An archive of socialistresistance.org, 2002–2022

Asylum campaigning: Is amnesty the right road?

 |  Socialist Resistance pilot issue October 2002  |  page 20

This is newsprint, transcribed by hand. The automatic reading of this page cut the article up and welded its columns together, so the text below was transcribed from the page image instead. It should be free of the usual OCR faults. The scanned issue remains the authority.

"Mr Blunkett should consider the radical option of declaring an amnesty. He should give all asylum-seekers currently here the right to remain, and start again."

So wrote the Independent newspaper on September 16 2002, in response to the news that the current dispersal programme had been suspended to the Sunderland area following the recent murder of an Iranian asylum seeker Peiman Bahmani.

The article pointed out that the Home Office had recorded 2000 racial attacks on asylum seekers since the dispersal programme started two years ago – and that it had previously suspended dispersal to Glasgow after the murder of Firsat Dag on the Sighthill estate.

The paper was further critical of the fact that politicians on both government and opposition benches had whipped up racism by their use of inflamatory words such as "bogus" or "swamped" when referring to asylum seekers.

Of course the Independent does not call, as many campaigners do, for an end to all immigration laws. It sees amnesty as a means to make the existing system work more efficiently rather than fighting for open borders.

But its call has been welcomed by the National Coalition of Anti-Deportation campaigns and in fact reflects discussions that had already started within the anti-racist movement.

It is certainly clear that asylum seekers and those that campaign in their support are facing a many pronged political and practical offensive by this new Labour government.

The treatment of the Ahmadi family, whose removal to Germany the High Court found to be unlawful, is just one of the more high profile examples of the fact that removals are being stepped up.

While the court judgement was an important success, the family have not been allowed to return to Britain while their appeal against deportation is heard.

The continued government offensive may seem like a strange context for campaigners to discuss going on the offensive by putting forward new demands – which is what focusing on amnesty would involve.

And clearly the context of such a campaign in this country would be different from that for example in France where the demand for papers – which is in practice the same thing – has come from the sans papiers themselves.

Some activists have warned that this could be a dangerous road to go down in particular expressing concern that the movement could end up being arbiters of those "deserving" or not "deserving" of amnesty.

This is particularly based on an assessment of what happened when the 1974 Labour government introduced an limited amnesty – which ended up trapping those who didn't fall into its provisions but none the less came forward and identified themselves to the authorities and were therefore removed any way.

Presumably this happened because those affected misunderstood the terms of the government's decision – something that obviously happens in many situations.

However this is neither what is being talked about by the Independent nor by anti-racist campaigners. It is remarkable that the Independent's call refers to all current asylum seekers – rather than categorising them in any way. That is its strength.

Of course what would actually be achieved through any campaign would depend on the balance of forces. A partial amnesty might at some stage be offered and campaigners would then have to evaluate whether this involved acceptable compromises from their point of view.

But there are strong arguments for going down this road. As David Blunkett himself has been forced to point out in giving evidence to the Commons Select Committee, there is no chance that the government can meet its own targets for removals. The reality is that the system is falling apart.

This therefore is a good time to make a move as the appearance of the Independent article suggests.

We want to take the political initiative rather than always react to what the government is meting out.

We want to fight for full rights for all those who are made illegal by asylum and immigration laws and practice. At the minute we tend to focus on asylum seekers but in fact significant numbers of those without legal status or rights are overstayers – who are now increasingly being targeted by immigration officials.

In developing these discussions, activists also want to look in more detail at experiences from other countries.

There is, in any case, an increasing need to work towards Europe-wide demands and co-ordinations as, despite many differences, Fortress Europe increasingly shapes the context in which we are all working.

Hopefully, the European Social Forum in Florence will be an important focus for deepening such exchanges.

Campaigning to Defend Asylum Seekers

Barbed Wire Britain: www.barbedwirebritain.org.uk, 01865 558145

Campaign to Defend Asylum Seekers: www.defend-asylum.org, [email protected], 07958 478 628

National Coalition of anti-deportation campaigns: www.ncadc.org.uk, e-mail [email protected], phone 0121-554-6947, or 020-7701-5197 or 0161-740-8206