Socialist Resistance

An archive of socialistresistance.org, 2002–2022

Salma's vision for Respect

Socialist Resistance no48  |  page 6-7

This is scanned newsprint, not web text. The original PDFs carried no text layer at all, so every word here was read off the page by OCR. Expect dropped opening letters, run-together words and wrong characters. There was no contents page to cut the paper up by, so the articles were found from the size of their headlines: a headline may carry its kicker, and where an article ran beside a boxed panel a few lines of the neighbour can appear. The scanned issue is the authority; this text is here so the words can be found at all.

"The fact that Respect has won a serious base in some Muslim communities is a tremendous achievement for all ofus. For the first time, a part of the genuine left has sunk deep roots in some of the most disadvantaged communities in the country. In a period where racism is on the rise, and multiculturalism is under attack, the importance of this is hard to overestimate.

We have been much weaker in areas where this combination of factors is not as strong. ...

There are whole swathes of white working class areas that feel abandoned. We need an honest discussion inside these areas, apart from rhetoric. is the key to ensuring strong local candidates and every potential Respect candidate should aim to be a "community leader" if they are serious about trying to win. Part of our role is to be able to bring the respected and rooted local activist (or (community leader') into the wider progressive alliance that we have created, and for us all to be strengthened by this common ground. ... the big political issues and addressing

alternative now. Respect about what we have committed to

consensus. Sustained local community activity

We need to combine in our local work both a commitment to campaigning around

divide it." ways these link to specific local issues that impact on people's day-to-day lives.

We need to work consciously and patiently to consolidate and extend our vote in our existing strongholds. And, where we are weaker, we need to begin to act as if we were already local councillors. The crisis of political representation extends right down to ward level. We have to be willing and able to offer an

... We have an opportunity to show, in practice, that we are a home for those seeking an alternative to the right wing

There are many more people outside Respect, who share many of our principles but who, for a variety of reasons and party loyalties, may not join us at the moment. Our willingness to be open and flexible in co-operating and sharing ideas and experiences is vital for the future of us all.

My vision for Respect is of a coalition which acts to support all those who share a commitment to peace, equality and justice. In building Respect we have to act in a way that strengthens this broad progressive constituency and does not in which they can function. as a convincing alternative that can win support from trade joint slate in these elections...

...Respect has to have a political life separate from its political work, and prioritise building a collective, inclusive pontical party which can conecavise ponical experience New Labour, which in our view should also run an active the Morning Star/CPB. done so far at national and local level to build Respect." trade union left that there is a democratic space within Respect

Also - partly as a result of Respect's failure to promote itself union leaders - the RMT is considering standing candidates in the GLA elections. We should welcome this development - but do everything it can to reach an agreement with the RMT for a participating organisations. Its leading members have to be in a position to make building Respect a genuine priority in their leadership that sets out to draw together the strengths and the talents of all the currents and independent forces that rally to Respect. In our view that means taking on the character of a

... The conference in November needs to build a new and broader unity in the leadership bodies and make the necessary changes which can take the organisation forward and build it as a broad, active, high-profile, campaigning party to the left of publicity machine and a high profile campaigning publication.

This would present a strong and credible appeal to the left in the trade unions, the demoralised left in the Labour Party and to

Any other answer threatens to undermine all of the gains that have been made so far, and all of the good work that has been

The ISG also published these articles on its own website — read that text

The International Socialist Group, which produced Socialist Resistance, carried the paper's articles on its own site as well. The text below is that site's own HTML, recovered from the Internet Archive, so it carries none of the OCR faults above. It is not a correction of the printed article: the two versions differ, and the printed page remains the text of record. This scanned record runs 2 pieces together, which the ISG published separately as “Salma Yaqoob refutes allegation of “communalism””, “Extract from a statement to Respect NC”.

Salma Yaqoob refutes allegation of “communalism”

“The fault line of “communalist politics”’ in Birmingham has most recently been between African-Caribbean and Asian communities who often feel in competition with each other over council funding. These tensions tragically ignited in Lozells where two young people lost their lives. There is no political figure in Birmingham more closely associated with trying to address these tensions than myself.

That is why I initiated the women and children’s Peace March in the aftermath of the Lozells riots which received very high local news coverage. That is why Respect supporters took great risks, behind the scenes, to ensure there was no retaliation from Pakistani gangs in the aftermath of the desecration of Muslim graves in Handsworth cemetery.

When I spoke from the platform of the recent Jesse Jackson rally to a 600 strong (and overwhelmingly African-Caribbean) audience, I used my time to call for black and Asian unity. It is not accidental that I was the only politician to speak at the recent march in Lozells against Gangs and Guns organised by the Council of Black Led Churches.

Furthermore, both in my newsletters and within the council chamber I have specifically championed the issue of poor educational attainment of white working class boys from disadvantaged backgrounds.

If I wanted to pander to conservative pressure inside the Muslim community, appearing on Question Time and opposing the imposition of Islamic dress on women, opposing the criminalisation of women in the sex industry, or opposing homophobia in the local media, would not exactly be the best way to go about it!”

Salma’s vision for Respect

“The fact that Respect has won a serious base in some Muslim communities is a tremendous achievement for all of us. For the first time, a part of the genuine left has sunk deep roots in some of the most disadvantaged communities in the country. In a period where racism is on the rise, and multiculturalism is under attack, the importance of this is hard to overestimate. We have been much weaker in areas where this combination of factors is not as strong. …

There are whole swathes of white working class areas that feel abandoned. We need an honest discussion inside Respect about what we have committed to these areas, apart from rhetoric.

… Sustained local community activity is the key to ensuring strong local candidates and every potential Respect candidate should aim to be a “community leader”’ if they are serious about trying to win. Part of our role is to be able to bring the respected and rooted local activist (or (community leader’) into the wider progressive alliance that we have created, and for us all to be strengthened by this common ground. …

We need to combine in our local work both a commitment to campaigning around the big political issues and addressing ways these link to specific local issues that impact on people’s day-to-day lives. We need to work consciously and patiently to consolidate and extend our vote in our existing strongholds. And, where we are weaker, we need to begin to act as if we were already local councillors. The crisis of political representation extends right down to ward level. We have to be willing and able to offer an alternative now.

… We have an opportunity to show, in practice, that we are a home for those seeking an alternative to the right wing consensus.

There are many more people outside Respect, who share many of our principles but who, for a variety of reasons and party loyalties, may not join us at the moment. Our willingness to be open and flexible in co-operating and sharing ideas and experiences is vital for the future of us all. My vision for Respect is of a coalition which acts to support all those who share a commitment to peace, equality and justice. In building Respect we have to act in a way that strengthens this broad progressive constituency and does not divide it.”

Extract from a statement to Respect NC

Alan Thornett, John Lister

“The objective conditions which produced Respect, and the space to the left of Labour, remains in full-force, as shown by the Shadwell result. Brown leads a right-wing, anti-working class, neoliberal government, which has continued the Blairite relationship with the employers, and is even more hostile to the unions, as his pay freeze makes clear. …

Despite the politics of new Labour, Respect has not fulfilled its potential politically or organisationally. … Respect needs to build itself as a national organisation. This means a stronger national profile and much more attention to building local branches. It needs effective fund-raising.

In our view in the longer term the strategic issue is whether Respect should be a political party or a loose coalition. We have argued that the loose coalition model - or “united front of a special kind” or whatever - does not work. We believe that challenging for political power taking on all other political parties and dealing with all the problems that arise needs the structures of a political party:

This does not mean that we believe Respect is, or could sensibly be declared to be, a party in any sense at the present time. A process of development is required to make this a possibility.

Meanwhile we agree that even as a coalition Respect could be far more effective, proactive and dynamic: we agree with both George and Salma when they underline the need to organise Respect as a coalition in a much more coherent and inclusive way, and to raise its profile.

The recent Morning Star article by Rob Griffiths, raising the issue of the need for a new party, is an important development. We have to promote a dialogue with such potential allies and build their confidence in what we are doing. We cannot simply say “here is Respect, it is the best thing around (which is certainly true) and you should join it”.

We have to show them that we are a serious, active, inclusive, campaigning organisation. If Respect is to seriously build itself, it has to convince those coming from the labour and trade union left that there is a democratic space within Respect in which they can function.

Also - partly as a result of Respect’s failure to promote itself as a convincing alternative that can win support from trade union leaders - the RMT is considering standing candidates in the GLA elections. We should welcome this development - but do everything it can to reach an agreement with the RMT for a joint slate in these elections…

…Respect has to have a political life separate from its participating organisations. Its leading members have to be in a position to make building Respect a genuine priority in their political work, and prioritise building a collective, inclusive leadership that sets out to draw together the strengths and the talents of all the currents and independent forces that rally to Respect. In our view that means taking on the character of a political party which can collectivise political experience.

…The conference in November needs to build a new and broader unity in the leadership bodies and make the necessary changes which can take the organisation forward and build it as a broad, active, high-profile, campaigning party to the left of New Labour, which in our view should also run an active publicity machine and a high profile campaigning publication. This would present a strong and credible appeal to the left in the trade unions, the demoralised left in the Labour Party and to the Morning Star/CPB.

Any other answer threatens to undermine all of the gains that have been made so far, and all of the good work that has been done so far at national and local level to build Respect.”