He argued that to deserve the label "ecosocialist":
firstly, should banish the purely propagandist approach to ecological questions, based on a mere denunciation of capitalism. Instead, we should improve our knowledge of the problems, not only in their social but also in their scientific dimensions (the latter being partly independent of the first);
secondly, we should help to build broad mobilisations on ecological demands and learn from others. In my view, the absolute priority from this point of view is the building of a world mass movement in favour of social and equal solutions to stop climate change (and adapt to it because it is already here).
Nonetheless, the challenge of climate change illustrates the adequacy of Marx's concept: capitalism destroys the climate because its logic of accumulation unbalances the exchange of matter through a process of continual intervenabout land reform and tax Guatemala, the CIA organised coming from quite different
A round of workshops folsion on "you have to be red to which capital has been able to strengthened, from previous unconstrained and invasive incompatible with capitalist
In the intervening period intensify the struggle between the experiences of fighting the workshop suffered from eral discussion to elaborate on defend the environment with
One thing we haven't done
of everyday life. whole pattern of consumption which takes people with us. That means avoiding the use of taxes because for the rich and the middle class everything is cheap, but not for the working class.
We can't impose things on the working class that will damage their material standards of living.
Neo-liberal capitalism has swivelled production in the advanced countries towards luxury production. This benefits about 15% of the world's population. I think that means that the campaign to defend the environment is going to really take off in Britain and internationally.
You can see video footage of some parts of the day on our web site at http://www.socialistresistance.net/
The next issue of Socialist Outlook which will be out later in January will carry in full the contributions of Daniel Tanuro, Derek Wall and Andy Kilmister.
The ISG also published this on its own website — read that text
The International Socialist Group, which produced Socialist Resistance, carried the paper's articles on its own site as well. The text below is that site's own HTML, recovered from the Internet Archive, so it carries none of the OCR faults above. It is not a correction of the printed article: the two versions differ, and the printed page remains the text of record. The ISG titled it “Getting to grips with the climate change agenda”.
On December 2, Socialist Resistance hosted a forum on Ecosocialism or Barbarism in London. A packed programme of workshops and plenary sessions brought together people from a variety of different backgrounds in a stimulating day of discussion which will hopefully have an impact on our practice in the New Year of 2007.
Belgian environmentalist Daniel Tanuro opened the day with an account of his explorations of Marx from an ecosocialist point of view. But while highly developed and argued in close detail, his contribution was much more than an intellectual one.
He argued that to deserve the label “ecosocialist”:
firstly, we should banish the purely propagandist approach to ecological questions, based on a mere denunciation of capitalism. Instead, we should improve our knowledge of the problems, not only in their social but also in their scientific dimensions (the latter being partly independent of the first);
secondly, we should help to build broad mobilisations on ecological demands and learn from others. In my view, the absolute priority from this point of view is the building of a world mass movement in favour of social and equal solutions to stop climate change (and adapt to it because it is already here).
Nonetheless, the challenge of climate change illustrates the adequacy of Marx’s concept: capitalism destroys the climate because its logic of accumulation unbalances the exchange of matter through a huge saturation of the carbon cycle.
He was joined on the platform of the opening session by Dr Derek Wall, the male Principal Speaker of the Green Party of England and Wales and a life long ecosocialist.
Wall spoke about the Ecosocialist manifesto written by Joel Kovel and Michael Lowy which he argued “is an essential document because it argues in essence that unlimited economic growth is unsustainable and that to survive, capitalism must grow for ever. It calls for an alternative to this system of madness...
At the start of the industrial era, there were 220 parts per million (ppm) of carbon dioxide in the atmosphere and now there are 450ppm and I believe that CO2 will stabilise at something like 700ppm with disastrous result.
The Blair government is planning to spend £20bn on Trident. Iraq, far from being the exception, is part of a process of continual intervention.
At the behest of the United Fruit Company, worried about land reform and tax threats to their activities in Guatemala, the CIA organised a coup which helped to radicalise a young medic known as Che Guevara. The Ecosocialist Manifesto helps make the connection between all these events”.
Klaus Engert from the WASG in Germany and Socialist Resistance’s Jane Kelly also made powerful contributions in the session and in the brief time there was for discussion from the floor there was an interesting communality of approach despite the fact that people were coming from quite different experiences.
A round of workshops followed. Shelia Malone’s session on “you have to be red to be green and you have to be green to be red” is reported elsewhere on the spread. Klaus Engert’s workshop which spanned both this and the next session on Alternative solutions was organised in a way that is unusual for such events on the British left.
Participants were divided into small groups and given a list of questions to work though after a brief introduction from Klaus and then came back together to feed back their ideas.
The emphasis was on work… and the idea to get people to imagine what a low carbon society could be like. A challenge which those than participated really liked.
Andy Kilmister.s session on how the market tries to coopt the environmental movement was more conventional in its organisation but posed a number of important questions. He explained that.The reason why Marx attached such importance to commodity fetishism was the key role it played, and continues to play, in making capitalist social relations appear ‘natural’ and unchangeable.
Relationships between people which can potentially be changed through political struggle come to be seen as immutable since they arise from a permanent natural order.
Exactly the same is now happening with climate change. Rather than being seen as something resulting from the particular pattern of human relationships which capitalist development presupposes, it is analysed as a technical problem which needs to be solved within the framework of the existing social order.
Looking at how capitalism has used periods where the productive forces have been destroyed through war, he drew out the differences between that and climate change as follows:
“There is one important difference.between crises occurring as a result of ecological upheaval and those which have arisen through war. Ecological imperatives such as climate change not only devalue existing capital; they also place very significant constraints on the capital which can replace it.
This marks a fundamental change from the ways in which capital has been able to emerge, often temporarily strengthened, from previous crises. In the past, a central characteristic of capitalist production has been its unconstrained and invasive nature, noticed by Marx and Engels as far back as the Communist Manifesto.
The recognition of ecological limits, of which climate change is currently the most important, may ultimately be incompatible with capitalist accumulation of any kind. In the intervening period it will greatly sharpen and intensify the struggle between labour and capital over the resolution of the crisis”.
In the second session of workshops the new contribution was that on Popular ecology in the south which saw Esperanza Sanchez talk about the documentary she had made on the erosion of glaciers in Peru and her frustration at the extent to which climate change was not seen as a priority by the popular movements - including in Venezuela where she lived for a year, and from Jose Colque from the Bolivia Solidarity campaign who spoke about the experiences of fighting water privatisation and defeated mutinational company Bechtel.
With two introductions, the workshop suffered from being a little squeezed for general discussion to elaborate on the interesting questions that had been raised.
In the final session Amacay Colque from the Bolivia Solidarity Campaign further drew out the lessons of intergrating the struggles to defend the environment with those to emancipate people in a powerful contribution.
Socialist Resistance’s Phil Hearse concluded with the following observations: One thing we haven’t done in recent years is to make a critique of everyday life.
Socialists have tended to say “the working class has more and can consume more and that’s a good thing”. But the whole pattern of consumption in late capitalism is crazy.
It’s a pernicious ideology. Whole sectors of the population are tied into it. Where is the working class family that’s going to explain to their children that they aren’t going to have Christmas this year because lots of this consumption is irrational?
It’s going to require a “reconversion” of the way we live, thinking about what it means to be human and what are the things we need and the things that this society says we need. Now I’m not suggesting that we need to start living in something like a medieval village again. There’s no question of going backwards in terms of peoples standards of living. We have to do it in a way which takes people with us. That means avoiding the use of taxes because for the rich and the middle class everything is cheap, but not for the working class.
We can’t impose things on the working class that will damage their material standards of living.
Neo-liberal capitalism has swivelled production in the advanced countries towards luxury production. This benefits about 15% of the world’s population. I think that means that the campaign to defend the environment is going to really take off in Britain and internationally.
You can see video footage of some parts of the day on our web site at http://www.socialistresistance. net/
The next issue of Socialist Outlook which will be out later in January will carry in full the contributions of Daniel Tanuro, Derek Wall and Andy Kilmister.