Socialist Resistance

An archive of socialistresistance.org, 2002–2022

Galloway must show members some respect

Socialist Resistance no32  |  page 3

This is scanned newsprint, not web text. The original PDFs carried no text layer at all, so every word here was read off the page by OCR. Expect dropped opening letters, run-together words and wrong characters. There was no contents page to cut the paper up by, so the articles were found from the size of their headlines: a headline may carry its kicker, and where an article ran beside a boxed panel a few lines of the neighbour can appear. The scanned issue is the authority; this text is here so the words can be found at all.

George Galloway was the first MP to break with Labour to the left. He was a central leader of the biggest anti-war movement Britain has ever seen. and prepared to be expelled for his uncompromising stand.

Respect emerged as a loose coannon belween George Galloway, the SWP, other socialists, and Muslims radicalised against the war. This was inevitable in the circumstances, but it was never a viable model on a long-term basis. What was always posed was how to develop Respect into a political organisation that could take on all-comers, on the full range of issues, in the cauldron of party politics.

Ultimatelv it would have to be organised as a party - whatever it was called. A loose coalition could not have MPs in Parliament, local councillors, or run councils which has been the plan. That would lead to disaster.

This was never going to be easy given the range of opinion within Respect. George Galloway was strong on the war, anti-imperialist and antineoliberal but weak (or worse) George Galloway and the SWP both want a loose structure for Respect for their own (slightly different) reasons on aspects of social policy. And there are faith groups in Respect alongside the far-left.

The problem is that the process of building any political coherence has never ever started. In fact it has been strongly opposed at each stage by George Galloway and the SWP, who both want a loose structure for their (slightly different) reasons.

After George Galloway won Bethnal Green and Bow last May, which was a tremendous achievement, things got worse.

He has become increasing unaccountable. His personal 'audience with George Galloway' tour was an example of this. He was famously mure ano a one or mese when New Labour survived by a majority of one on a key

on the "anti-terror" measures. Respect was damaged as a result.

The paper also published this on its own website — read that text

Socialist Resistance ran its own site at socialistresistance.net before it moved to WordPress, and this article appeared there too. The text below is the paper's own HTML, recovered from the Internet Archive, so it carries none of the OCR faults above. It is not a correction of the printed article: the two versions differ, sometimes by a fifth of their length, and the printed page remains the text of record.

George Galloway was the first MP to break with Labour to the left. He was a

central leader of the biggest anti-war movement Britain has ever seen, and

prepared to be expelled for his uncompromising stand.

Respect emerged as a loose coalition between - George Galloway, the SWP,

other socialists, and Muslims radicalised against the war. This was

inevitable in the circumstances, but it was never a viable model on a

long-term basis. What was always posed was how to develop Respect into a

political organisation that could take on all-comers, on the full range of

issues, in the cauldron of party politics.

Ultimately it would have to be organised as a party ­ whatever it was

called. A loose coalition could not have MPs in Parliament, local

councillors, or run councils -which has been the plan. That would lead to

This was never going to be easy given the range of opinion within Respect.

George Galloway was strong on the war, anti-imperialist and anti-neoliberal

but weak (or worse) on aspects of social policy. And there were faith groups

in Respect alongside the far-left.

The problem was that the process of building any political coherence has

never even started. In fact it has been strongly opposed at each stage by

George Galloway and the SWP,- who both want a loose structure for their own

After George Galloway won Bethnal Green and Bow last May, which was - a

tremendous achievement - things got worse.

He has become increasing unaccountable. His personal "Audience with George

Galloway" tour was an example of this. He was famously in Ireland at one of

these when New Labour survived by a majority of one on a key vote on the

"anti-terror" measures. Respect was damaged as a result.

What was developing was precisely the wrong relationship between a party and

its only MP and only nationally known figure.

When accountability ­ and there can be no democracy without accountability ­

came up at the Respect conference last November, Galloway¹s approach was

defended by the main component in Respect, the SWP: "Don¹t worry George it_s

only a coalition" was the message!

Whether serious attempts to develop democratic and accountable norms inside

Respect would have prevented George Galloway taking his disastrous decision

to go on Big Brother we will never know.

What we do know is that the failure to establish any accountability made it

far easier for him to do it, and therefore more likely. It was a disaster

Huge damage has been done to Respect as a result of his decision; only time

will tell the full scale of this. But the lessons have not been learned even

When the Respect National Council first met to try to deal with the

situation there was opposition to a proposal to issue a clear statement to

the membership on the issue of accountability. It was argued that this could

result in George Galloway resigning from Respect.

We are very much against a split with George Galloway over this, if it can

be avoided. His reputation can be rebuilt if he goes about it the right way.

Publicly this means accepting that Big Brother was a serious error of

judgement. In Respect it means accepting that he was wrong to take that

decision unilaterally ­ and that he will do things differently in the

There has to be a principled basis for a continuing relationship. Otherwise

Respect is providing foot soldiers for an unaccountable MP.

Respect was to be a different kind of organisation: more democratic, more

accountable, less media spin and more rooted in the movement.

To ensure it has a future, it must live up to this.