Socialist Resistance

An archive of socialistresistance.org, 2002–2022

The Danish cartoon controversy: Free speech, press freedom and the right to offend people (continued)

Socialist Resistance no32  |  page 2

This is scanned newsprint, not web text. The original PDFs carried no text layer at all, so every word here was read off the page by OCR. Expect dropped opening letters, run-together words and wrong characters. There was no contents page to cut the paper up by, so the articles were found from the size of their headlines: a headline may carry its kicker, and where an article ran beside a boxed panel a few lines of the neighbour can appear. The scanned issue is the authority; this text is here so the words can be found at all.

variety of more and less extreme Muslim organisations are continuing in various countries, in opposition to the publication in a Danish daily paper of cartoons satirising the prophet Mohammed.

The episode highlights the vexed issue of freedom of speech, and the extent to which the freedom to give offence must be defended.

We defend the right to publish the cartoons, although Socialist Resistance would not opt to do so, since they would gratuitously give offence, and hand a weapon to extremist and reactionary elements within the complained that nobody dared illustrate his book about Mohammed, for fear of death threats similar to that endured by Salman Rushdie.

Islamic tradition bars pictorial depictions of the Prophet, although this oft-repeated injunction has on several occasions been breached before without causing controversy.

Images circulating on the Internet now show bombs exploding over pictures of the newspaper, and blood flowing over the national flag and map of Denmark. What started out as a Danish journalistic project has now expanded into a global controversy.

The paper's Editor-in-Chief, Carsten Juste, said, "We live in a democracy. That's why we can use all the journalistic methods we want to. Satire is accepted in this country, and you can make Caribalures

"Religion shouldn't set any barriers on that sort of expression. This doesn't mean that we wish to insult any Muslims."

He also said, "We must quiThere are important principles which need to be defended.

One of these is that the right to freedom of opinion and expression is a fundamental right that safeguards the exercise of all other rights.

It is a critical underpinning of democracy and applicable not only to "information' or 'ideas' that are favourably received, but also to those that offend, shock

Some of the cartoons published in the Danish paper may well be offensive to many Muslims (and may well be offensive to others, including cartoonists - some of the published cartoons are of poor quality), but charges of offence and blasphemy should not be deployed to curtail freedom of expression.

The Campaign for Press and Broadcasting Freedom's position is that restrictions on freedom of expression which privilege certain ideas or beliefs cannot be justified. European newspapers are also being put under unacceptable pressures, which can compromise the freedom of the the door in 2004" but was cleared of four counts for derogatory statements against asylum seekers. Anti-fascist campaigners will be watching the retrial closely. New York City Members of the Transport Workers Union (TWU) Local 100 in New York City have rejected the contract put to them by their leadership and the Metropolitan Transit Authority (MTA) by a mere seven votes.

As a response to the rejection, the MTA has called on the state to convene a panel that will force a contract on the union which has put back into the contract the increase of pension payments for new hires.

TWU President Roger Toussaint has said the union "downright reject" the attempt to impose a contract. La Paz Newly elected Bolivian President Evo Morales named prominent social movement activists to cabinet positions and halved his pay by 50% in order to pay for new teachers in the country.

Morales also signed agreements with Venezuela's Hugo Chavez on trade and called for an "anti-drug alliance" with the United States. Lisbon fascism there. Havana printed across it. tal for one of the three worldwide World Social Forum's calling for "another Africa in another

Debates were held between two main currents in the global justice movement in Africa, those in favour of compromising with neo-liberalism and those of the more radical wing. Rightist candidate Anibal Cavaco Silva won the presidential election making him the first right-wing politician to do so since the fall of The US Interest section in Havana has installed an electronic billboard which displays US news and a scrolling text of the UN declaration on human rights.

Cuba has responded by placing billboard across from the Interest Section with photos of US troops abusing prisoners at Abu Ghraib and a swastika with the word "Fascistas!" Dunfermline and West