Socialist Resistance

An archive of socialistresistance.org, 2002–2022

Respect conference adopts policies One step forward

 |  Socialist Resistance no20  |  page 4-5

This is scanned newsprint, not web text. The original PDFs carried no text layer at all, so every word here was read off the page by OCR. Expect dropped opening letters, run-together words and wrong characters. There was no contents page to cut the paper up by, so the articles were found from the size of their headlines: a headline may carry its kicker, and where an article ran beside a boxed panel a few lines of the neighbour can appear. The scanned issue is the authority; this text is here so the words can be found at all.

The Respect conference on October 30-31 had many strengths. The conference took a series of decisions that took the organisation closer to the pluralist, democratic, campaigning socialist political party to the left of labour that is so desperately needed and that Respect has the real potential to become.

Around delegates attended, and at least 100 observers, though most not for the whole time, a weekend CYCILL that discussed and debated - and usually agreed policy on a whole range of issues of international and national politics.

It was a pleasant change from many conferences of the radical left that many of the participants were from number of different ethnic minority communities, reflecting the real strides forward Respect has made in this regard.

What was agreed will undoubtedly give the incoming National Committee a real basis to develop a rounded general manifesto and the organisation issues to campaign around.

Conference started with a session imperialism opened by councillor Oli Rahman, from Tower Hamlets, our first elected representative.

Lindsay German, secretary of the Stop the War coalition as well as a member of Respect's outgoing national executive also made an introduction in this session.

Conference went on to debate 10 resolutions, starting with a very comprehensive statement from the National Executive Council and agreed or remitted everything in this section.

Things seemed a bit flat at this point, but that is not that surprising.

The war in Iraq was the driving force that brought the coalition together, so you would not expect there to be a huge amount of disagreement over it.

Conference was then addressed by the General Secretary of the PCS, Mark Serwotka and went on to Ken Loach argued for a paper with in-depth policy supplements debate the emergency resolution calling for solidarity with the November strike. Serwotka's speech - see box -was definitely one of the highlights of the weekend.

There were then a series of workshops Kashmir, Kurdistan, Palestine, Civil Liberties and trade unions (see box). After lunch conference considered the motions relating to these issues first. This did get frustrating.

It was clear for example from the Kashmir workshop that there was a wealth of knowledge on the subject as well as ideas for practically campaigning around the issue - and building Respect more strongly in the relevant communities. But one speech of 3 minutes can't explain 57 years of occupation and broken promises or why it came to pass never mind what we should do about it.

That these problems are ones that arose in a new organisation at its first conference is no real surprise.

There were more than 70 resolutions for conference to consider over two days as well as a load of other business.

On publications, the executive supported the stronger amendment from Oxford, which commits Respect to producing a national publication for sale before the general What was agreed will undoubtedly give the incoming National Committee a real basis to develop a rounded general election manifesto and the organisation issues to campaign around. And we reached the end of the order paper - unlike for example most trade union conferences that remit masses of stuff to the incoming executive to ignore.

OK so there was stuff remitted but this was on the decision of the mover - even if it sometimes seemed that EC members had influenced this decision.

Perhaps we need to look at future conferences at limiting the number of motions that each branch can submit -while also perhaps bringing in a provision for branches to submit motions they don't agree with but believe are worthy of debate.

Both provisions exist for example in the procedures of the Scottish Socialist Party and this, together with other practices have worked to ensure that conference considers motions properly and that there is a culture of pluralism and dissent.

There are other issues that

needs to address about procedures. The standing orders were a little thin and in retrospect it was a mistake not to give movers of motions the right of reply, not to be clear who decided whether speakers would be taken in debate etc.

We have no proper procedures for compositing, either in terms of when it should take place or what the rules are for doing it.

This is not anyone's fault -it is just how it is but we should learn from our weaknesses and inexperience and ensure that we are better prepared for the next conference.

Alarm bells rang more loudly with some of Saturday afternoon's debates. A session on youth and crime might better have been separated in

two, or called "New Labour's attempt to criminalise young people".

Then the final debate of the afternoon on abortion definitely left a bitter taste in people's mouths. It is certainly a big step forward that Respect adopted a position of defending the existing legislation and supporting woman's right to choose.

Defence of the existing, albeit inadequate legislation, opens the door for more developed discussion and positions to be taken by Respect in the future.

Conference supported the composite motion moved by comrades from the SWP but voted against the two other motions one from Resistance supporters and one from the CPGB.

It was a great pity that the guillotining of the discussion, twenty minutes before conference was due to end, meant that the debate could not be properly had and left women who had wanted to speak very frustrated.

Everyone knew this was one of the most contentious debates of the weekend and it should have been given adequate time. And this basic lack of democracy was a problem to some extent or another throughout much of the conference.

Socialist Resistance is not hostile to the alliances the SWP have managed to make within Respect with ethnic minority and Muslim groups in principle.

We believe these alliances can strengthen Respect and deepen the fightback against Blairism. But there can be a danger of bending to the perceived views of some of allies, in an opportunist fashion.

For example there is no evidence that all Muslims are opposed to abortion and anyhow, even if some of them are they can vote against such resolutions.

If the adoption of such positions leads to them leaving Respect, when they agree

The paper also published this on its own website — read that text

Socialist Resistance ran its own site at socialistresistance.net before it moved to WordPress, and this article appeared there too. The text below is the paper's own HTML, recovered from the Internet Archive, so it carries none of the OCR faults above. It is not a correction of the printed article: the two versions differ, sometimes by a fifth of their length, and the printed page remains the text of record.

The Respect conference on October 30-31 had many strengths. The conference took a series of decisions that took the organisation closer to the pluralist, democratic, campaigning socialist political party to the left of labour that is so desperately needed and that Respect has the real potential to become.

Around 280 delegates attended, and at least 100 observers, though most not for the whole time, a weekend event that discussed and debated - and usually agreed policy on a whole range of issues of international and national politics. What was agreed will undoubtedly give the incoming National Committee a real basis to develop a rounded general election manifesto.

Conference started with a session on imperialism opened by councillor Oli Rahman, from Stepney Green and St Dunstan's ward in Tower Hamlets, our first elected representative. Lindsay German, secretary of the Stop the War coalition as well as a member of Respect's outgoing national executive also made an introduction in this session. Conference went on to debate 10 resolutions, starting with a very comprehensive statement from the National Executive Council and agreed or remitted everything in this section.

There was a bit of a hint that things were a bit flat at this point, but that is not that surprising. The war in Iraq was the driving force that brought the coalition together, so you would not expect there to be a huge amount of disagreement over it. The withdrawal of a motion written before the National Executive statement had been seen by the branches didn't in itself raise any alarm bells either.

Conference was then addressed by the General Secretary of the PCS, Mark Serwotka and went on to debate the emergency resolution calling for solidarity with the November 5 strike. Serwotka's speech - see box - was definitely one of the highlights of the weekend, .....

There were then a series of workshops on Kashmir, Kurdistan, Palestine, Civil Liberties and trade unions.

The Kashmir workshop for example was extremely positive. Forty people crammed into too small a room to hear a speaker from forward4kashmir explain why the war in one of the most militarised part of the world is almost never heard of here - and that even the left ignores it most of the time. As well as supporting the subsequent resolution on conference agenda, the session was extremely informative and comradely one in which people actually made contributions which responded to what had been said rather than a series of pre-prepared speeches in parallel to each other.

The Kurdistan workshop was very different but again very heartening in that the 3 platform speakers from the region all had different political approaches and therefore led to a genuine debate on the way forward - while maintaining the minimum basis for solidarity that conference would later adopt by passing the motion on the issue.

The workshop on Palestine not surprisingly focused on the disagreements that exist between people moving motions and amendments on the question later on. In particular the section in the Waltham Forest motion which supports the establishment in the whole of Palestine a unitary, democratic and secular state. Only this would allow for the recognition and implementation of the Palestinian right to return to any part of Palestine and for the abolition of all discriminatory Zionist legislation. Others proposing the Grenwich amendment wanted the deletion of this clause, apparently because the Palestinians themselves are not demanding a unitary democratic state and we should not impose our demands on them. Yet, those in favour of the amendment pointed out that Mustapha Barghouti, a prominent Palestinian leader had declared "the 2 states solution dead". The argument also conflated the role of a solidarity organisation like the Palestine Solidarity Committee and a political party in embryo like Respect.

After lunch, conference considered the motions relating to these issues first. This did begin to get frustrating. It was clear for example from the Kashmir workshop that there was a wealth of knowledge on the subject as well as ideas for practically campaigning around the issue - and building Respect more strongly in the relevant communities. But one speech of 3 minutes can't explain 57 years of occupation and broken promises or why it came to pass never mind what we should do about it.

That these problems are ones that arose in an new organisation at its first conference is no real surprise. There were more than 70 resolutions for conference to consider over two days as well as a load of other business. And we reached the end of the order paper - unlike for example most trade union conferences which remit masses of stuff to the incoming executive to ignore.

OK so there was stuff remitted but this was on the decision of the mover - even if it sometimes seemed that EC members had influenced this decision. Perhaps we need to look at future conferences at limiting the number of motions that each branch can submit - while also perhaps bringing in a provision for branches to submit motions they don't agree with but believe are worthy of debate. Both provisions exist for example in the procedures of the Scottish Socialist Party and this, together with other practices have worked to ensure that conference considers motions properly and that there is a culture of pluralism and dissent

There are other issues that Respect needs to address about procedures. The standing orders were a little thin and in retrospect it was a mistake not to give movers of motions the right of reply, not to be clear who decided whether speakers would be taken in debate etc. We have no proper procedures for compositing . This is not anyone's fault - it is just how it is but we should learn from our weaknesses and inexperience and ensure that we are better prepared for the next conference.

Alarm bells rang more loudly with some of Saturday afternoon's debates. It really isn't very intelligent to call a session youth and crime if you want to attract the people who are being Asboed to your organisations and as for the final debate on abortion, that definitely left a bitter taste in people's mouths.

It was bad enough to be told that while we should support a womans right to choose but not tell anyone about it, but when women who had put in speakers slips to support the eventually defeated Islington motion were denied the right to speak - so that conference could finish 20 minutes early then it was difficult not to be spitting blood.

It is certainly a big step forward is that Respect has a position of defending the existing legislation and supporting a woman's right to choose. But there was nonsense talked in this - and in other debates about trusting our representatives which means not holding them to account.

Sunday morning was a new day started by George Galloway opening the debate on electoral strategy (see box). The impressive session that followed saw many comrades talking about their experience on the ground - and illustrated that the SWP have obviously changed their view during the course of the debate. Initially they were arguing for 50 seats as distinct from Galloway's 25-30, but Galloway had clearly won the day. At it has to be said that his arguments come over as very convincing. Meanwhile the position originally put forward by Nick Wrack, that we need to stand in at least enough seats to get an election broadcast, despite being argued in a motion from…which was withdrawn and gained virtually no hearing on conference floor.

In this session too, we debated the question of publications. Socialist Resistance supporters had been instrumental in putting a series of motions on this question. We hoped that the weaker of these, calling for a feasibility study might just about be agreed but we were pleasantly surprised to hear just before the discussion that the executive were supporting the stronger amendment from Oxford, which commits us to a publication for sale before the general election. This meant the debate was less focused than it might have been otherwise, but never the less the agreement to these resolutions was an important step forward.

Conference then dealt with the other outstanding policy motions relatively quickly.

The score for the issues that SR had pushed wasn't bad

Appeal to LP/SP - agreed

Lesbian and Gay rights - Agreed

For a small organisation we had managed to have a significant effect - and Respect seemed to be moving in the right direction.

Of course the debate on self organisation was still to come, but to was difficult to believe that something that is policy in virtually every trade union, every other left party in Europe and is supported by SWP members in all those places wouldn't be agreed.

But in the debate on the constitution the worm turned. Actually it happened just before that. I don't actually remember what Michael Lavalette was supposed to be talking about when he launched his viscious attack on dissidents within Respect. He called those moving the resolution on a worker's wage "divisive and dishonest" and set the tone for a flurry of speeches that would follow. Sait Atgul went on to move the constitution in a way that did nothing to commend him, icidently accusing (all?) those who had raised the question of abortion as being "cynical". Chris Bambery went further and attacked the idea that 20 members had the right to move motions to conference - but he was not called as a speaker against the constitution that has this provision in.

This was poison and left Respect weaker than it is or needs to be. The SWP as the largest organisation in Respect has a huge responsibility for its development. The SWP have done many positive things in building the anti-war movement and in building Respect over the last years and months. But it is particularly regrettable in a situation where they clearly have the numberical strength to win all their political positions that they choose to treat those who disagree with them in such a manner.

Socialist Resistance was successful in getting the majority of the political positions we wanted to see agreed at this conference adopted. We don't agree with many of the positions from other "dissidents" which were not adopted at this conference eg on workers wage and open borders and on some constitutional issues. But we believe that Respect in order to be a broad pluralist democratic socialist alternative to the left of labour needs dissidents, including those with whom we disagree. You can't pick your opposition comrades, and if you try you will weaken, perhaps fatally the whole project and lifeblood of Respect.