Late Blairism: A carnival of reaction
Socialist Resistance no13 | page 3
This is scanned newsprint, not web text. The original PDFs carried no text layer at all, so every word here was read off the page by OCR. Expect dropped opening letters, run-together words and wrong characters. There was no contents page to cut the paper up by, so the articles were found from the size of their headlines: a headline may carry its kicker, and where an article ran beside a boxed panel a few lines of the neighbour can appear. The scanned issue is the authority; this text is here so the words can be found at all.
Abraham Lincoln said that you can A fod all the people some of the
time, some of the people all the time, but not all of the people all the time. In the squalid last week of January, Tony Blair's government, aided by Lord Hutton, acted in defiance of this basic law of politics.
In the process they showed their utterly brutal right-wing face, the pathetic spinelessness of most Labour MPs and the Blairites' determination to push their own neoliberal, privatising, agenda to the end.
As the world now knows, the Labour backbench rebellion on tuition fees collapsed on Tuesday 27 January, when Nick Brown, the rebels' "chief whip' turned turtle and with a small group of similar pro-Gordon Brown friends, ensuring a government majority of just five - which would have been four if Labour MP David Taylor hadn't voted in both lobbies.
The mechanism by which this was done was bizarre - it boiled down to Charles Clarke giving an 'assurance' that in a year or so after the imposition of the new fees system, there will be a review of whether it is keeping students from poor backgrounds out of prestigious university courses.
Even a five-year old could see this 'assurance was worthless. When variable fees were introduced in Australia, they were capped at a maximum level, a cap that was subsequently abolished.
Anyone who has thought about the matter for five minutes can see that the same will happen here. According to the government's own figures, variables fees up to the £3000 maximum will bring in about £l.5 billion, against the £1l billion deficit which universities face.
This means that for absolute certain, in a few years time universities like Oxford, Cambridge, Imperial College and the LSE will be charging €15,000 a year - £45,000 in fees alone for an undergraduate course.
Even for less prestigious universities, the £3000 figure will be revised upwards, allegedly to keep pace with inflation. The net consequence of all this is that the class bias of higher education will be brutally reinforced, keeping poorer students away from elite colleges, and - faced with the prospect of huge post-graduate debts - out of higher education altogether.
All but the dimmest Labour MP must understand this. They must also know the government is pushing hard for universities to maximise commercial sponsorship, bending academic research even more to the priorities of multinational corporations, on the model of that well-known institution in the Fens, Cambridge Microsoft University Inc.
Nick Brown, former agriculture minister and GMB northern region organiser, was tipped the wink to capsize the opposition by his boss Gordon Brown.
The Browns calculate that by 'saving' Tony Blair, they have revealed who really has the power and the ability to lead - just as Boris Yeltsin's saving of Mikhail Gorbachov during the 1990 attempted coup, was the prelude to replacing him.
Whether the Browns are right or not, who knows? What we do know is they allowed a hugely unpopular measure to go through parliament based on petty bureaucratic calculation. This unedifying spectacle was witnessed by a nation hugely opposed to these variable fees, where only very rich families for whom everything is cheap, can afford to be indifferent.
f Blair, Clarke and the Browns defied all
logic, Lord Justice Hutton the next day
defied belief in exonerating the government, and finding only the BBC and Dr David Kelly were at fault.
In producing such a one-dimensional whitewash, Lord Justice Hutton has flabbergasted not only the chattering classes, but also the mass of public opinion.
On the day after publication, the BBC's Question Time held an interactive poll to which 23,000 people replied; 82% said the report was a whitewash. Channel Four News held a poll to which 32,000 people replied, and 90% said the poll was a whitewash.
At a purely bureaucratic and parliamentary level, Alistair Campbell's tactic of diverting claims that the government 'sexed up' its dodgy dossier into an attack on the BBC, has - with the excellent help His Lordship - brilliantly succeeded.
In fact it succeeded so well, that it has transcended its immediate objective and contributed to longer term objectives of Late
The paper also published this on its own website — read that text
Socialist Resistance ran its own site at socialistresistance.net before it moved to WordPress, and this article appeared there too. The text below is the paper's own HTML, recovered from the Internet Archive, so it carries none of the OCR faults above. It is not a correction of the printed article: the two versions differ, sometimes by a fifth of their length, and the printed page remains the text of record.
Hutton and Tuition Fees: A Carnival of Reaction
Abraham Lincoln said that you can fool all the people some of the time, some of the people all the time, but not all of the people all the time. In the squalid last week of January, Tony Blair's government, aided by Lord Hutton, acted in defiance of this basic law of politics. In the process they showed their utterly brutal right-wing face, the pathetic spinelessness of most Labour MPs and the Blairites' determination to push their own neoliberal, privatising, agenda to the end.
As the world now knows, the Labour backbench rebellion on tuition fees collapsed on Tuesday 27 January, when Nick Brown, the rebels' 'chief whip' turned turtle and with a small group of similar pro-Gordon Brown friends, ensuring a government majority of just five - which would have been four if Labour MP David Taylor hadn't voted in both lobbies. The mechanism by which this was done was bizarre - it boiled down to Charles Clarke giving an 'assurance' that in a year or so after the imposition of the new fees system, there will be a 'review' of whether it is keeping students from poor backgrounds out of prestigious university courses.
Even a five-year old could see this 'assurance' was worthless. When variable fees were introduced in Australia, they were capped at a maximum level, a cap that was subsequently abolished. Anyone who has thought about the matter for five minutes can see that the same will happen here. According to the government's own figures, variables fees up to the £3000 maximum will bring in about £1.5 billion, against the £11 billion deficit which universities face.
This means that for absolute certain , in a few years time universities like Oxford, Cambridge, Imperial College and the LSE will be charging £15,000 a year - £45,000 in fees alone for an undergraduate course. Even for less prestigious universities, the £3000 figure will be revised upwards, allegedly to keep pace with inflation. The net consequence of all this is that the class bias of higher education will be brutally reinforced, keeping poorer students away from elite colleges, and - faced with the prospect of huge post-graduate debts - out of higher education altogether.
All but the dimmest Labour MP must understand this. They must also know the government is pushing hard for universities to maximise commercial sponsorship, bending academic research even more to the priorities of multinational corporations, on the model of that well-known institution in the Fens, Cambridge Microsoft University Inc.
Nick Brown, former agriculture minister and GMB northern region organiser, was tipped the wink to capsize the opposition by his boss Gordon Brown. The Browns calculate that by 'saving' Tony Blair, they have revealed who really has the power and the ability to lead - just as Boris Yeltsin's saving of Mikhail Gorbachov during the 1990 attempted coup, was the prelude to replacing him.
Whether the Browns are right or not, who knows? What we do know is they allowed a hugely unpopular measure to go through parliament based on petty bureaucratic calculation. This unedifying spectacle was witnessed by a nation hugely opposed to these variable fees, where only very rich families for whom everything is cheap, can afford to be indifferent.
If Blair, Clarke and the Browns defied all logic, Lord Justice Hutton the next day defied belief in exonerating the government, and finding only the BBC and Dr David Kelly were at fault. In producing such a one-dimensional whitewash, Lord Justice Hutton has flabbergasted not only the chattering classes, but also the mass of public opinion. On the day after publication, the BBC's Question Time held an interactive poll to which 23,000 people replied; 82% said the report was a whitewash. Channel Four News held a poll to which 32,000 people replied, and 90% said the poll was a whitewash.
At a purely bureaucratic and parliamentary level, Alistair Campbell's tactic of diverting claims that the government 'sexed up' its dodgy dossier into an attack on the BBC, has - with the excellent help His Lordship - brilliantly succeeded. In fact it succeeded so well, that it has transcended its immediate objective and contributed to longer term objectives of Late Blairism - to permanently hobble public service broadcasting and to put the frighteners on broadcast journalists who might be mildly critical of the government.
After the ousting of Gavin Davies and Greg Dyke, Chair of BBC governors and Director General respectively, the apology offered to the government by acting chairman Lord Ryder was denounced as 'groveling and demeaning' by as mild a liberal as David Attenbrough. What we see with Hutton's report and this 'apology' is a return of social deference, of respect for our superiors, unseen since the 1960s. Among leading parliamentarians it was left to Michael Portillo to demand total independence for the BBC.
In fact, a point made by this journal several times, BBC journalists were on the whole uncritical of the government during the Iraq war. But there are bigger issues at stake. The vultures have been circling the BBC for years, and leaders of the pack are Rupert Murdoch and leading BskyB executives. What they want is a reduction of the role of public service broadcasting to that which it has in the United States; an arena for the production of minority interest programmes, with small funds and little chance to make effective mass audience programmes. Hence the apparently 'high brow' criticisms of the Greg Dyke's role at the BBC, claiming too much money was being spent on mass entertainment programmes like Fame Academy, to win the ratings war with ITV.
Rupert Murdoch wants the BBC to be left with the opera and the archeology, pushed out of the ratings wars, and de-gutted as an effective mass broadcaster in Britain and around the world. Anyone who has had the misfortune to recently watch CNN or other North American channels recently knows exactly what this means. The limited voices of criticism and dissent we have here on British TV and radio would be pushed out completely in a Murdochised system. With the BBC marginalised, critical spaces on ITV channels would be under pressure as well.
It is ironic of course that the departed heads of the BBC, Gavin Davies and Greg Dyke, were put there as loyalist Blairites. Davies, a multi-millionaire from investment bankers Goldman Sachs, was among the first prominent business people to swing behind Blair in the mid 1990s, and open up contacts and support in business circles. An ever-further rightwing Blairism chews up and spits out its loyalists, as the long list of ex -Labour ministers on the back benches reveals.
Irony upon irony, all this comes just when Bush's own appointed weapons inspector, David Kay, tells Congress that there were no weapons of mass destruction. Forget all the nonsense about 'intelligence failings' which 'must be investigated'. Intelligence agencies produced the dodgy dossiers, which their masters wanted. Andrew Gilligan was right.
In the last year there have been three great issues, which defined Late Blairism - foundation hospitals, the Iraq war and tuition fees. These issues and the battles around them show the utterly reactionary character of the Blairite project. At its heart is the deepening of class inequality and the promotion of social deference and imperial power. Millions of people now understand this. What they need is an effective political voice to represent them.