Socialist Resistance

An archive of socialistresistance.org, 2002–2022

Halliday attacks NLR, Tariq Ali

This was not a Socialist Resistance publication. marxsite was Phil Hearse’s own long-form site, run alongside the paper he helped edit. It is kept here with his agreement, recovered from the Internet Archive after the domain lapsed and was taken over by someone else; nothing here links to the address it now points at.

As credited on the page: “Original at Skidmore”

Where this article was first published has not been established, so it is not reproduced here. marxsite reprinted it in full; this archive does not.

An interview with Fred Halliday, recorded in Chicago in November 2005, in which he breaks publicly with the politics of the journal he helped edit. Halliday sat on the New Left Review editorial committee from 1968 until he resigned in 1983, and here tells Danny Postel that he no longer shares its major political orientations. The quarrel is over the Middle East and over anti-imperialism: he objects to the way his former comrades — Tariq Ali above all, whose standing had risen sharply after 11 September — understand responsibility for the region's wars and the forces contending in them. marxsite carried it as the other side of an argument, linking the original rather than endorsing it.

Précis by Red Mole.

Read it at the archived copy of the marxsite page.