Socialist Resistance

An archive of socialistresistance.org, 2002–2022

Review: Alaska or Iraq?

Socialist Resistance magazine, issue 59  |  printed page 31

This is scanned print, not web text. It was read off the printed page by OCR, so expect dropped opening letters, run-together words and the occasional wrong character. Where an article began partway down a page, the previous piece's closing lines may appear at the top. The scanned issue is the authority; this text is here so the words can be found at all.

Irag? In this powerful and graphic account of his time in Iraq, Jamail tells the real story of the war in Iraq. Jamail was an American working in the the Alaskan wilderness as a mountain guide and sometimes volunteer mountain-rescue ranger. As the build-up to the invasion of Iraq became apparent he was disgusted with the "cheerleading for war" feebly disguised as "journalism' that corporate media television stations and newspapers in his country was disseminating. something about it; something very brave. He saved up money to buy a camera, a lap-top and a plane ticket. For him the choice was simple: "either to stay in Alaska and suffer the frustration and impotence of watching all this happen or take a risk to get the information I know to be the truth out to others".

Following the invasion, in November 2003 Jamail flew to Jordan, hired a driver and crossed the border into Iraq. For most western journalists the option was to be 'embedded' with an army unit or report from inside

the 'Green Zone' (the heavily

fortified and US controlled secure

stronghold in central Baghdad)

relying on the US military

personnel to provide information

about what was going on.

For Jamail this was

something he couldn't do. For

him the government of his

country had told lies which

were obediently repeated by an

unquestioning media in order

to justify the invasion and

occupation, and he says he "felt

that i had blood on my hands

because the government had

been left unchecked".

His journeys in the Red

Zone to interview ordinary Iraqis about events found him in constant danger for his life from the invading forces, as un-embedded journalists and those not putting forward the official position found themselves in the sights of the allied military.

On the ground Jamail found he was constantly witnessing a different story than that being portrayed by the military and western mainstream media.

Continually arriving at incidents he found the figures didn't add up - instead of a 'fire fight' with 'opposing forces' Jamail found himself interviewing relatives of dead Iraqi civilians (many of the dead being children, women and the elderly) who had been slaughtered by the Americans simply because earlier in the same area there had been an attack by the Iraqi resistance.

This retribution also often meant the bulldozing and wrecking of civilian homes and having the electricity and water supplies cut. All too often he found that young Iraqi men,

civilian farmers or shopkeepers,

had disappeared to languish for

months inside the notorious

Abu Ghraib or other detention

centres, without charge, and

with their distraught relatives

unable to get any redress.

Jamail reports on the

brutality of unchecked

mercenary forces such as

Blackwater USA, the corruption

and misappropriation of monies

by large U.S. corporations, such

as Halliburton and Bechtel,

which run into billions of

dollars; money that was paid to

deliver unfinished projects. He

also reports on the farce of the

supposed democratic elections

31 Shaming the embeds As if his life was not already in grave danger, he made the decision twice to get into Fallujah when in April and November 2004, the city was under siege and under attack by the American forces. In harrowing accounts he documents the breeches of the Geneva Convention so often, and in so many ways, by the

...the use of illegal weapons such as cluster bombs and white phosphorus munitions; having 'free-fire zones' in civilian areas; taking over hospitals, shooting ambulances; not allowing the dead to be buried and the wrecking of places of worship and killing those at prayer."

Jamail's continuous output of reports on the radio and the internet has won him much praise; John Pilger said of him:

"For me, he is the finest reporter working in Iraq... he shames the flak-jacketed, cliché-crunching camp followers known as 'embeds?'

He has reported from the

besieged city of Fallujah, whose

destruction and atrocities have

been suppressed by Western

broadcasters, notably the BBC."

Beyond the Green Zone

describes the life of ordinary,

everyday, Iraqis and their

suffering under the Americans.

So often the people cannot

understand the brutality of

the invading forces that are

portrayed to the world as

liberators. More importantly,

it again opens up the debate of

war reporting and the power

of the compliant media in the

message it sends out on behalf

of governments.

What about the aftermath

of war and the continued

page 32 of the scan

Socialists working 32 occupation of Iraq?

Bush slipped out of the back door, when he could find it; and Blair, it seems, continues to slip off the hook of retribution. Jamail compares the 1968 massacre of My Lai during the Vietnam War, when American soldiers massacred Dave Hill, a supporter of Socialist Resistance is standing as a candidate for the Trade Union and Socailist Coalition (TUSC).

He writes: more than 400 innocent civilians-the majority of whom were women, children and the elderly—to Fallujah, when, during the November siege, an estimated 5,000 innocent civilians-again, the majority of whom were women, children and the elderly-were together The TUSC campaign in Brighton

Kemptown has been going very

well. Comrades from Socialist

Resistance, the Socialist Party,

SWP, RMT, the Trades Council,

Defend Council Housing, and

Alliance for Green Socialism are

all involved, by giving financial

support, and/or by joining us

in campaigning, supporting

picket lines and local campaigns

(such as anti-cuts, and save our

nurseries campaigns), leafletting,

canvassing. We've started!

In Brighton, job cuts-including

101 job losses threatened by

Brighton Council-and threats

to services are major issues, as

are international issues like Gaza

and the Iraq/Afghan Wars.

We protested against the cuts

and job losses in early March,

and our Brighton TUSC launch

meeting on Tuesday 9 March

drew together Bob Crow, RMT

leader, Hannah Sell (Socialist

Party) and me.

Offers of help with canvassing

and leafletting will still be much

appreciated!

My hope is that trade unions and

socialist/ Marxist parties working

together in TUSC will lead to an

arrangement with Respect, and

the creation of a mass workers'

party to the left of Labour, with

socialist policies and trade union

support. slaughtered

Most US citizens know nothing about what really has happened in Iraq, Jamail says, "thanks to the corporate media, which has done such a fantastic job in whitewashing the impossible."

He questions the future of The Brighton TUSC Facebook page is at http://www.facebook.com/#!/ group.php?gid=328024422940 &ref=nf The Brighton TUSC blogspot is at http://brightontusc.blogspot. com/ Vote Dave Hill for Brighton Kemptown